Have your say: Is safe exit to Isayas of Eritrea worth considering?
The recent Gambian crises has been a good lesson to many Africans and should be debated throughout the continent. The reason this needs to be debated is the continent is facing with aging authoritarian leaders
The recent Gambian crises has been a good lesson to many Africans and should be debated throughout the continent. The reason this needs to be debated is the continent is facing with aging authoritarian leaders who cling to power and are insecure, and fear of retributions from the people or their opponents once they leave power. If we see African countries from north all the way to south, it is full of authoritarian regimes from Albert-Bernard Bongo of Gabon, Teodoro Obiang Nguema Mbasogo of Equatorial Guinea, Idriss Deby of Chad, Ismaïl Omar Guelleh of Djibouti, Denis Sassou Nguesso of Congo, Abdelaziz Bouteflika of Algeria, Omar H.A. Al-Bashir of Sudan, Robert Gabriel Mugabe of Zimbabwe, Paul Biya of Cameroon, José Eduardo dos Santos of Angola, Yoweri Museveni of Uganda, Isaias Afwerki of Eritrea, Paul Kagame of Rwanda,Abdelaziz Bouteflika of Algeria, Salva Kiir Mayardit of South Sudan,
Jammeh of Gambia came to power through a military coup and cling to power for centuries and even used to boast by vowing to reign in power for a billion years. Jammeh like many other African leaders has deceived his people by pretending as a religious figure, who has a higher calling to save the Gambian people, but he had no internal convictions nor any moral compass to lead people.
In Africa, the authoritarian leaders fear election and election related processes like implementing constitutions and abiding by rule of law. Some entertain their humble people by conducting an election dramas and often succeed in doing so. But for some leaders those types of snare tactics won’t work and even costed them a lot, losing their long lasting reign and is a live trap like what happened for Gambia’s president. Often those leaders conduct non-transparent elections either to legitimise their continuity in power by seducing poor people or due to the pressure from international communities to do elections. Jammeh also conducted those elections for any of those reasons, however, the recent election was not like the other once. Immediate after the election he conceded defeat, without realising he is in a big trouble and it is going to cost him his billion years reign. Similar elections in several African countries ended up manipulated by the ruling regimes either during voting or counting and they guarantee their continuation in power by intimidation and use of force.
Gambia’s recent election was a different one Jammeh was not able to manipulate the result, who knows he was busy collecting the gold and silver of the country and did little attention to the developments in the election processes. Here comes a million dollar question to all Africans; can an authoritarian ruler leave power peacefully?
Or is it worth considering a safe exit for all the exciting dictators in Africa for the sake of peace and to avoid bloodshed, displacement, and more social crises that come with unseating them militarily? Gambia’s recent events teach us a lot, and the regional group The Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) leaders should be applauded for their effort and for trying all windows of peaceful negotiations. If it was not for the wisdom of those leaders the country could have ended up in a disaster and in a lot of bloodsheds.
The safe passage to president Jammeh was a good negotiating deal and resulted in immediate peace and hope among the people. Though some still disagree on the deal and may choose to see him caught in Gambia and put in jail. After noticing all the atrocities and human rights abuses and selfish desires of these dictators one cannot deny the voice those who oppose the deal but we need to thoughtfully examine the consequences if not succeeded. History thought us a lot, in many African countries a military intervention or military coup to unseat an authoritarian ruler have had a negative outcome with the emergence of either of the following; a new young brutal dictator, an authoritarian party, or a family member of the ousted dictator his son or daughter or brother. Hence what had happened in Gambia can be agreed as a good deal to the Gambian people they are left with a democratically elected president and, peaceful transition leaving aside the issue of emptied banks. The question comes how much can we compromise?
My main idea as the topic shows is to invite everyone who reads this small introductory article to come and discuss/debate an important issue that affects all Eritreans. The topic is;
“Is safe exit to Isayas and his accomplice worth considering for the sake of peace?”
Let us discuss and debate and brainstorm our thinking now as this will happen sooner or later.
We cannot avoid history and what happened in Gambia or other African countries will happen to us and a sense full discussion without emotion could save us a lot.
Thank you
Mulugheta
Teclay January 25, 2017
Hello! Hello !!!!!!
Please ,before you talk,about African dictators or our Issu in particular,you have to ask and answer yourself …….’Why do African dictators become dictators ??? Are African leaders, presidents as they claim or WAR LORDS ??? ‘
How can one govern an African country with out being a dictator ????= A multi ethnic and multi religion forged country can not be ruled by democracy but by war-lords……..So the only durable solution is to abolish the forged arbitrary colonial borders…….Is it bitter to swallow ??? = yes ,i know ,but that is the right medicine ….
eri January 25, 2017
HEY THE CIA DISCLOSED OLD SECRET DOCUMENT THERE IS A LOT ABOUT TPLF AND EPLF
YOU GUYS WILL LIKE IT
Ahmed Idris January 25, 2017
If the long-time leader 27 Years Mr Afewegi , who continue been in power despite losing popularity, is due to his uncertain future.
Experience shows that dictators can get a dignified exit .like the case of Eritrea’s long time leader ,if they put an end to the undeclared emergency laws imposed in Eritrea since September 2001 , released the G15 and all the political prisoners,
Set foundation for national reconseliation and transitional justice. Revives 97 constitution and activities the parliament. .
If he would do in the rest of his presidency period in building democratic enterprises. .
Judicial and legislatives excutives. .and free press ..free political parties ,the freedom for staging demonstration. .free civic societies
Free ,fair and transparent election. .
Peaceful transition of power. .
Then he might deserve a calm retirement. .enjoying seeing his legacy in building interprises that strong enough to prevent the country from sliding into chaos and civil war as a result of his long ruling totalitarian regime which is scraping all political life ,in Eritrea.
Then Mr. President can be guaranteed free exit. .and not be prescuated by ICC..in all the crimes he commented aganist the Eritrean people. .
We need to learn lessons from Gambia in how to get rid of dictators without sliding into conflict and civil war. .
ኣርዓዶም January 25, 2017
Isaias should not allowed to leave the country, he should pay the price what he did to our people and country. He should face the same method of Mohamed Gezafi of Libya, he should be hanged for 7 days in the ceiling.
Isaias did more more uncountable crime than Mohamed Gedafi of Libya, Isaias and Hgdef should face the force of the people and enlisted out of the map of Eritrea for ever.
Keshi Mars January 25, 2017
Hello Asenattat, it is good to entertain ideas. Well sth comes out of it. Though my idea of making a dictator can be different and the solution I present to solve it, yes to your question. If ever the gang agrees, to the idea of safe exit, I might go even further to cover its expense for one year.
Almaz January 25, 2017
Rubbish article and nonsense … There is NO comparison at all period! …… Our president Isaias (I like to spell it Isaias) is not a tyrant or came to be a leader by overthrowing (coup d’état.) He is a leader born and matured in a struggle. For the sake of us (the million), we pray he stay in the position he is now for a little longer. In fact, Isaias and Kagame (Rwanda) leader are the ones who can be emulated by other progressive leaders. Isaias is a role model for all anti-capitalist leaders of Africa who are only to pocket wealth with doing a little to the natives. Unlike most of us screen heroes here, The leadership of Eritrea Isaias, in particular, is the one who works untiringly day and night for the good of the country. with pay not comparable to their position. Comparing him t o the ex-leader of Gambia is idiotic.
Hope PFDJ improve some of the country policy towards integrating private investment and open up a somehow to ligament small business (eg construction.)
So long
yemane January 25, 2017
Dear Eri, I think woyane made you out of two legs and hands somewhere in the passed border war. because your comments are always about woyane. even the article was out of that matter. or else you are from tsetserat where mentally ill persons are treated.
Eri January 25, 2017
Yemane
Most of the commentators are from agameland like you shaming naming our country and chaos to our people so I like to open their eyes and that they are
The cancer of the Horn of Africa .
You like andom aka ADGOM naming villages that you or your father remember shelter you and feed you and for thanks you robe them
AHMED SALEH !!! January 25, 2017
Issaias has the right for safe exist as president according the history of African corrupted political
culture . Time to stop this kind irresponsible approach that sends wrong message for high rank
government officials lawlessness practices . Rule of law shouldn’t be compromised if we wish to
build future constitutional government .
How many of them received immunity for the crimes committed and corruptions that failed entire
continent ?
Now after 25 years we expect issaias personality suddenly will change overnight . GOOD-LUCK .
Ask him first to pardon Eritrean patriots and innocent population in prisons under his watch then
we may say now his heart seems to show little mercy .
Eri January 25, 2017
Ahmed tell me what is his crime ??
And what solid evidence you have without your usual propaganda
alem January 25, 2017
Kubroum namete b martelo endaketketka tezeykionu ayridean eyu. Nska dma adey amete eka.
Eri January 26, 2017
Alem kedamit
Shut up welfareki suq ilki bilii
Sol January 25, 2017
The ex-dictator of Ghana, in his last hours before he left the country has rooted 11 million American dollars and only God knows how much money he stole on his long time ruling the poor country.
Sol January 25, 2017
እዚ ርጉም ፍጥረት ኤሰያስ ዝብልዎ ኤርትራ ከይኣጽነተ ብድልየቱ ካብ ዝፋን ክወርድ ማለት ሕልሚ ደርሆ እዩ።
እዚ ርጉም ፍጥረት ኤሰያስ ዝብልዎ ኤርትራ ከይኣጽነተ ብድልየቱ ካብ ዝፋን ክወርድ ማለት ሕልሚ ደርሆ እዩ። ዝፋን ዘበለኒ ናይዚ ጸይቀ ግኑን ዘረባ ዘኪረ ሓደ ግዝየ ተንኮለኛ ኤሰያስ ክምዚ ኢሉ ተዛሪቡ ነሩ “እዚ ተቓሊስና ዘምጻእናዮ ዝፋን ብቐሊል ክንሓድጎ ማለት ዘበት እዩ”