The Sarcasm, Denial and Lies of the Eritrean authorities: a personal account on the National service, the closure of the University of Asmara and the Scholarship program in South Africa – Part III
Zekarias Ginbot February 3, 2015 ……..in Part I, I described how the aspirations of the Eritrean people have been dashed by PFDJ over the last 20 years and how the national service has ended up becoming a
Zekarias Ginbot
February 3, 2015
……..in Part I, I described how the aspirations of the Eritrean people have been dashed by PFDJ over the last 20 years and how the national service has ended up becoming a modern day slavery. In Part II, I continued to reflect on my own experience while inside and outside Eritrea including the closure of the University of Asmara. This final part, Part III, is about my own escape and life experiences outside Eritrea.
Part III
The closure of the University of Asmara in September 2006 was the ultimate disappointment to the university’s staff and students and to any Eritrean who understood the value of education. The university did not have new admissions then for two years, so the closure was in the making. But some people thought second year students might be sent to the university from the MaiNefhi College. We thought those students especially the ones in the natural science fields would require practical laboratory training to qualify for the degrees and diplomas as there was no laboratory setting at MaiNefhi. It is worth to note here that there was no communication in advance between the ministry of education and the university community until the last minute. The plan to close the university was just a rumor. This is common under PFDJ administration rather than exception. They first propagate rumors to measure public response and their cynical directives follow. They also use these same methods to propagate fear among the people.
When I came back to Eritrea as a fresh master’s graduate from the University of Cape Town at the end of 2002, I had never thought all these could happen. I had big ideas and a big motivation to work at the University of Asmara and contribute my part. But PFDJ had its own plans for the University, and they still claim that the University was not closed. Some of my teachers, who became colleagues later, at the University of Asmara, who taught for years were forced to leave the country and some of them were put aside. It was a sad occasion to witness the University closed after about 50 years of turbulent existence. Even the Ethiopian rulers did not dear to close it during the war for independence. Instead of strengthening the existed and established university, PFDJ chose to close and substitute it with sub-standard, military-run colleges. This has not been heard of in any other country as it is difficult and takes a long time to establish an internationally accredited institute like the University of Asmara was. Its closure and the issues associated with it has been described by many colleagues; I have just raised the subject here as my own tribute to what happened.
I always defended my coming back from South Africa when friends challenged me, but I really regretted when the university was closed. As I indicated in part II, I actually went to MaiNefhi for a couple of days when ordered to do so and was given courses that I was supposed to teach. I saw the students being treated like prisoners in a compound surrounded by military check-points. There were reports of beatings and military punishment of students who tried to jump over the fences. The moral of the students was at its lowest point and the situation was getting worse day by day. In my meeting with my would-be-students at MaiNefhi, I actually told them that I was not going to continue to teach them. I gave them some course material to help them with whoever was going to take over the course. I felt very sorry for them but what else could I do! PFDJ made it difficult for all of us. By then, some close colleagues have already left the country. It was not an easy decision; I had to leave and my family had to re-locate. I had to find someone who could assist me to escape. All these had to take place in a short period of time and without attracting attention of security agents.
I arranged for my escape to the Sudan but then my guide-to-be, who lived in Keren, was identified and abducted the night before the planned departure date. When I called, his terrified wife picked up the phone but then she was scared to tell me what happened. I was forced to tell her the travel plans on the phone so that she could tell me the truth. Then I had to talk to the person who introduced me to the guide about the situation and to get an advice. This latter person confessed to me what he knew; he himself had suffered tremendously in the hands of PFDJ security agents before and that he had to safe his own life. He decided to leave with me and we had to leave the town immediately before security agents capture us. We observed suspicious movements of people around the place where we had an earlier appointment with the then-captured guide and we had to hide. We left the town of Keren, but after three days’ journey towards the west, we lost our direction and were captured in the town of Teseney. It was night; we approached the town thinking that it was Kessela, the Sudanese town near the Eritrean border and were captured by the security agents.
The border security agents took our ID cards and were taking us, I did not know where to, and I told my colleague that I had to escape (using my tribal language). He was a welder by profession in his 50’s and I was a 36 years old university lecturer at the time. I thought they were to kill me not because I have read more X’s and Y’s than him, but because they would consider me more threat. They would also think I would tell my story louder if I survive the punishment and above all, I was already black-listed in their books. I did not wait to hear my colleague’s response. I jumped over the fence into a compound and continued to run from one house to another until I got to the edge of the town. People in Teseney and in other towns in the lowlands of Eritrea sleep outside, in front of their house and when I jumped into their yards some woke up and wondered around and their dogs barked. I believe this made it inconvenient for my pursuers to shoot me or re-capture me. I am sure I also out-run them as I was running to safe my life. I continued to run out of the town for a couple of minutes more and then laid down on the ground to avoid visibility as the moon was so bright. I could see, about 150 meters away, my pursuers searching the houses on the edge of the town.
I stayed laid on the ground for some time until my pursuers moved to the next neighborhood and then walked further away from the town. I did not know where I was and I had to stop and sit for a while to determine the direction from the movement of a shade of a stone against the moon light. It took me three more days to reach to safety. The distance between Teseney, the Eritrean near-border town and Kessela, the Sudanese town on the other side of the border was not that long but I was badly injured and dehydrated; and I had to travel at night only. I survived as I was able to drink water and eat some food on the second night when I met a farmer who was staying at his farm. He had a little left over from his dinner and I am very grateful to him to this day. It is in my wish-list to meet this person in the future and thank him for the water and food he provided me at the time of need.
I become very emotional and my body shakes when I remember my escape into the Sudan, but when I tell people about it including the details I left out in this written testimony; I get the feeling that some people might see it as a fiction. But when I tell this to fellow Eritreans who escaped in similar manner, they tell me of more horrific stories including the friends they left dead on the way. These days, I started to think of the kind of determination in the Eritrean youth to get away from the unjust PFDJ regime and I am struggling to find the reason as to why we do not show that kind of determination and take the risk to defy the regime inside Eritrea!. Wouldn’t the latter be more effective in solving the country’s problems like what has happened recently in some Arab countries? Is it possible that PFDJ, through the obligatory national military service and dirty propaganda, has instilled fear in us to see them as untouchable? I have my own assumptions on how PFDJ would react to an uprising, but I still need help to understand this and readers’ feedback will be invaluable.
In Eritrea, I heard many people cursing the ministers and local officials for all the misery but not Isayas Afeworki, the president. They thought that these officials were the spoilers and that if the president knew of the issues he would have solved them. I asked people in high office and found out that the president actually gets every detail of what happens in the country by a special group of people. So, he knows everything. But I also found out that the ministers and higher officials who chair meetings in the country and listen to people’s questions and grievances actually do not dear to tell the president what the people are complaining about. They just want to be seen as capable of decision making but talking to them can only put you in trouble. They can make you arrested and you can be forgotten there.
After leaving Eritrea, I meet Eritreans in the diaspora who blindly support the Eritrean government regardless of what is happening in that country. This undermines efforts by individuals and organizations who are working hard to awaken the people working for the system back home. There are also some ex-government officials who have abandoned PFDJ recently and claim that they themselves were in danger while in Eritrea. Some of them were terrorizing the people there. They now raise ethnical and tribal issues to indicate that PFDJ works on these bases and that they were discriminated against. We knew about these claims but they were the enforcers of such practices and they should have acknowledged and asked for forgiveness first. Furthermore, their ethnical and tribal disclosures are not helping others who are working hard to unify opposition against PFDJ, the dictatorial regime at home. It is worth to note that PFDJ itself is doing its best to divide the diaspora so that there could be no united opposition. Their supporters in the diaspora also pursue propaganda to show that there is no better option for Eritrea other than PFDJ.
I want to revisit here is the exodus of young people from Eritrea. It is shame that, despite our population size, we make up the second highest percentage of asylum seekers in the world at the moment. I do not believe that the Eritrean government is willing to address the root cause to stop it any time soon as they have already blamed other parties for promoting it. This issue will continue to affect us all for the foreseeable future. What I would recommend is to increase public awareness on the Eritrean situation wherever we are so that other countries could exert pressure on the Eritrean authorities to respect the rule of law. We need to make it clear to the world that there is no rule of low in Eritrea and our people are suffering in the hands of PFDJ government. Some European countries, such as Denmark, are getting the wrong information about the situation in Eritrea, primarily by talking to the Eritrean authorities or third parties that are not directly affected or involved. They are not talking to the right people and that we are not doing enough to expose the PFDJ regime. We need to convince these countries that the information they are getting from the Eritrean authorities is wrong and that they should investigate properly. We know what happened to those who were deported before.
Today, I am an associate professor with a PhD degree, trying to hold onto the passion I had in education despite being an asylum seeker in Europe. I believe I would have done a better and morally satisfying job in Eritrea than what I am doing now if PFDJ did not create the obstacles. The purpose of my testimony is to contribute to the efforts undertaken by other Eritrean individuals and organizations in increasing public awareness of the evil PFGJ. I believe a lot has been done to challenge the ‘Hade Wdib, Hade Hizbi, Hade Libi’ (One-Party-One-People-One-Heart) false propaganda of PFDJ. But we need to do more to convince Eritreans inside and outside the country that PFDJ can no longer deceive us and use the stalemate in the border issue with Ethiopia as an excuse to chock the Eritrean people. The Eritrean people deserve better. PFDJ should understand that there will be a time when they will face the consequence of their actions. In this regard, there is not going to be a better lesson in life than what has happened in Libya. There are still better options PFDJ could pursue rather than arrogance, deception and intimidation. The situation is already close to no turning point. The Eritrean people want real freedom, and they paid a huge price for it.
Peace, Freedom and Prosperity to the Eritrean people!!
Links to the Previous Parts:
Abrham February 3, 2015
Dr.Zekarias I am so delighted that you have made your way out of this tyrant dictatorship.
I was actually imprisoned with the man that you referred as “later person ” in your paragraph. He is a courageous man that dare to challenge this illegitimate regime. He helped us endure all the harsh interrogation and inhumane abuse that we faced from the servant of the regime. I personally believe it would have exposed the unlawful regime more if you had narrated how they blackmailed him (if you aware) to get released from their torture camps.
Tesfit February 3, 2015
Dear Assenna,
When you publish series of articles like this one, it is helpful to provide links to previous parts. It would be easy to follow. Thanks!
MightyEmbasoyra February 4, 2015
Tesfit,
Take this as an opportunity. Search for the previous papers. If you can’t find the search field at Assenna, create one and help Asenna. If you don’t know how to do that, learn some programming, and then help Assenna. This is everyone’s responsibility. Once you do that, you will appreciate Assenna and possible you will thannk me as well.
Genet-orginal February 4, 2015
Hi Mighty
nice to hear from you again.
I agree. people should be able to find the links, they are looking for themselves.
Genet-O
MightyEmbasoyra February 4, 2015
Hi Genet the original,
Like wise!
Zekarias February 4, 2015
Just to help you with the previous posts; here are the links:
Part I
http://demo.archive.assenna.com/the-sarcasm-denial-and-lies-of-the-eritrean-authorities-a-personal-account-on-the-national-service-the-closure-of-the-university-of-asmara-and-the-scholarship-program-in-south-africa/
Part II
http://demo.archive.assenna.com/the-sarcasm-denial-and-lies-of-the-eritrean-authorities-a-personal-account-on-the-national-service-the-closure-of-the-university-of-asmara-and-the-scholarship-program-in-south-africa-part-ii/
Zeray February 5, 2015
Hint for you Mr Tesfit
When the author said Part I and is in blue, all you have to do is press “Part I” and viola you go to the link etc..
Does that help?
tamrat tamrat February 4, 2015
Your story is a common denominator to assab refinery, eritrean air line, eritrean shipping lines, fishing industry, air force etc. All who could make the above sectors to be productive run away and serving others because of hgdef clueless policy. It is not that hgdef hates eritrea but this is what they can do best. They are like a spoiled brats who took over their father reach economy power. They don’t know how to run their father successful buisness and they dont trust any outsider. They just simply suck the business empire to ground zero while destroying the tousands employees and their familis lively hood.
MightyEmbasoyra February 4, 2015
Dr. Ginbot,
Thanks for sharing your story with Assenna’s family. This is another tragedy that we have heard it many times. Allow me to put some Cons and pros (have you notice I put Cons prior to pros? well, all I hear growing up is negative, so be easy on me). Ok, let me put pros first then.
Pros:
1. Glad to see you made it alive.
2. I am very proud of you for being an educated Eritrean.
3. Trying to be transparent by sharing your life history
4. Being brave. Many educated Eritreans are bullied by HGDF and kept quiet or sided with the criminals.
Cons:
1. Now that you are a PhD holder, the bar is so high and your articles need to be original, unless you are of course a historian.
2. You forgot or failed to explain on what you did to fix any issues you have seen, at least at UoA.
Over all, I have a very high respect for your achievements!
MES
Zekarias February 4, 2015
Dear all,
All your comments are constructive; by the way, you all know that negative comments also help us do better next time. Abraham, I hope you too are out of danger now.
Tebeges TeAges February 4, 2015
Dr.Zekarias,
I absolutely agree with you sir. The greatest threat to freedom is the absence of criticism. We also seem to lacking this in our Eritrean society very sadly.
Eritrawi February 4, 2015
The General Eritrean Story reminds me of another story told to me a while ago:
—
It is a story about four people: Everybody, Somebody, Anybody and Nobody.
There was a very important task to be done, and Everybody was sure that Somebody would do it. Anybody could have done it, but Nobody did it. This angered Somebody because it was Everybody’s job. Everybody thought that Anybody could do it, but Nobody understood that Everybody couldn’t do it.
In the end, Everybody blamed Somebody when Nobody did what Anybody could have done.
—
Such a tragedy Eritrea turned out to be… 🙁
Genet-orginal February 4, 2015
Dear Professor Zekarias
Your story is the Eritrean experience under Isayas Afeworki and the PFDJ system. We have, so many people who went through similar experience, yet not able to talk about it. It is good for you to write about your ordeal. I hope your writing will help you to cope better with life stress and help others to do the same.
Regarding the closure of the only University in Eritrea, I think that was a missed opportunity. It was the perfect time to raise up and turn the dictatorial gov upside down. After all, closing down the only University in our country was the ultimate assault of our future. Eritrean people are known to be appreciative of education. Isayas Afeworki, a first year college dropout himself, took advantage of our peoples’ naivety. He and his goon squad have been misleading our people about the difference between accredited Universities and community/technical colleges. Today, Eritrean people are confused about what is good or appropriate for their children, when it comes to education and everything else. Some even say, “before there was only one Asmara University, but now we have many universities”. The dictator and his supporters are robbing our country blind. DIA and PFDJ systme are telling lies to our people that their childen are graduating in all the fields in the world, without providing them the proper curricula or course of study. In reality, the only common thing they have with the rest of the world’s college graduates is the CAP and GOWNS. It is an assault on our future generation. It is the crime of the century. It is going to hunt us down for decade, if it is not for a century. We are in huge mess. On the other hand, we have people who are Asmara University graduates, who don’t see anything wrong about the closing of only University in our country. They know what it means, yet they are unconcerned. I don’t understand that. Professor, can you tell us how is that possible? Thank you.
Genet-O
MightyEmbasoyra February 4, 2015
Every time I see this probably the most famous building in Asmara, I have unique feeling. The sad part though, I didn’t get the chance (means grades) to attend there.
Did anyone exactly know why isiayas closed it? Is that because he doesn’t want to see many thousands of brilliant youths gathered in the middle of the capital city or he just wanted to ruin Eritrea? I always think which one of these were his first pick.
AHMED SALEH !!! February 4, 2015
Mighty
Issayas used to have problem with that university patriotic activists
at early stage of his political ambitions . Remember his contacts were
based more to those far away in Addis Abeba university . And he knows
well that the only way to secure himself from future threats had to
destroy that institution . I guess he succeeded to build politically
dominated education system run by his yes men which is contrary from
independent academic standards . I wonder if a student have freedom
to exercise his ability for new ideas or thoughts in that kind of
oppressive environment under military oriented supervision .
selamawit2 February 5, 2015
Hi Brother Mighty,
i think, it’s time for a cuppuccino…
MightyEmbasoyra February 5, 2015
Good to hear from you, Sis! Yes, it is about time. We should also invite few brothers and sisters to the nice aroma cappuccino!
selamawit2 February 7, 2015
The pleasure is all mine – i am also glad to read from you and all the other wonderful brothers and sisters. One day – i promise – i spend cappuccini for all of us.
(For those who wonder why we talk about cappuccino: Mighty had no chance to attend the University of Asmara. But he used to sit in Bar Lydia next to the university having the best cappuccini ever. This special Cappuccino became for me the a sign: Like Mighty, we people can be persons of integerity, intelligence and amicability without attending official learning institutes (e.g. universities) if we are driven by the hunger for understanding the world and constructive energy.
Of course it doesn’t mean, chances to attend universities should be missed, but if you don’t have the posibility, sometimes things are probably even more inspiring from the distance…
Weldu Birhan February 8, 2015
MightyEmbasoyra
higdef agents say it is because regionalist Embasoryans wanted to use it as an akeliguzay revolution. pathetic ?
oromay February 5, 2015
Dear writer,
You passed through dreamlike harrowing experience in attempt to safe your life. Such quandary stories have become routine in the lives of many Eritreans.
Some keen observers hinted the ill intentions of the belligerent regime right on the outset. You and many others did not know the behaviour of the militant regime until the time you realized its destruction actions become clearly visible to your senses. Dictators always hate literate citizen that is why the unhinged man appointed his loyal messengers to ruin the University right from the very beginning.One of the main agents of destruction dared to say that the internationally recognized University was in name. Just put it straight in recent interview, he said “It wasnot a University.”
Hagos February 5, 2015
Glad to hear that you escaped safely Zeca and are at safe place! Your ex-colleuage. Please forward me your e-mail. H.T.