Visit the new AsenaTv Website

https://asenatv.com

ድሃይ መርማሪት ኮምሽን ሰብኣዊ መሰላት ኤርትራ እንታይ ኣሎ?

ብ ዳንኤል መሓሪ (መታዓቢቲ) [gview file="http://demo.archive.assenna.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Elsa-letter-1.pdf"]

ብ ዳንኤል መሓሪ (መታዓቢቲ)

aseye.asena@gmail.com

Review overview
184 COMMENTS
  • Mebrat September 19, 2014

    for one reason or another elsa is bringing out the worst in people. some people are deviating from the most important points the writer raises. he is not talking about Akeleguazay. rather he is talking about corrupt practices, lack of transparency and accountability, creating chaos among Eritreans, mismanagement of resources obtained in the name of the Eritrean people, dealing with projects that concern human rights issues as if they were family business…..

    • Observer September 21, 2014

      Hi Mebrat,

      What is astounding is if there were indeed mismanagements, wouldn’t it have made sense to first and foremost engage with Elsa to get to the bottom of it? Why didn’t the Mr. Daniel start with that process? Secondly, we are taking everything he has laid out at face value. It is a very serious matter to accuse anyone with any sort of misappropriation. Without any substantiating evidence, what he has done here is nothing less than libel.

  • elos September 19, 2014

    wedi meriet zibehal , giega yiklaley ember asmat enaqeyayere zitsihif hade seb yu. wala ab qunaqun qalatun yifilet. hijis aselchuyuna beqa. embiza dima bezihu…zemed amanuel eyu mesleni wey dima amanuel yu.

    wedi meriet aleka do

  • kelifa gaym September 19, 2014

    Ane dhai kfelt ente anbebku ms arsti zey keykeyd nbab xenihuni. Nezi mizan zeyblu zereba kemey elom assena zergihemo aygermenn meknyatu n Elsa chrum nmkfa tebegisom zelewu media eyom. Ksab hji kumneger zelewo srah zserehe ente alo Elsa tray eya. Assena kem media shara zeyblu nkulu eritrawi khakuf zgbo, hji gn nay wshtom zwxau zelewu eyom zmeslu zelewu. Elsa mthbbar abyatna, genzeb bsm gdayat eritrawian zwexe nab rebha nata koynu z aynetu zereba ms mntay ykuxer.xhafai amanael eyassu keykone ayterfn ember sek elka do yzrgah ezi moral eritrawi ztnkf zereba walas ms hgdef rkb jemirkum ekum. Please amanael eyassu mefto shabia ay tgberuna.

  • Meretse Asmelash September 19, 2014

    ኣብ ከባቢ 1994 ዓ.ፈ ናይ ኢትዮጵያ ባህላዊት ክፍሊ ሙዚቃ መሪሑ ዝመጸ ነፍስሄር እያሱ ከምዚ ዝስዕብ ክብል ተዋዝየ። ሓደ “ ሃጸጸ” ዝብሃል ሰብ ማኪና ንምምራሕ ፈተነ ኣብ ዘካይደሉ ዝነበረ ግዜ፡ እቲ መምህር ምስ ኣካላት ናይታ ማኪና ከላልዮ እንከሎ ብቛንቛ ጥልያን ነበረ። ሃጸጸ ግን ነቲ ኣስማት ኩሉ መተክእታ ይረክበሉ ኔሩ። ንሱ (ሃጸጸ) ይብል ነቶም ክጥቅሶም ዝጸንሑ ቃላት ዝትክኡ ናይ ባዕልና ቃላት እንዳ ሃለወና ፣ ቃላት ጥላይን ምሕራዩ እንታይ ኣምጸኦ በሃላይ እዩ ኔሩ። ዝኾነ ኮይኑ፡ ድሕሪ ቁሩብ ግዜ ኣብቲ ምዕራፍ ናይ ምምራሕ ማኪና ምስ ተበጽሐ ፣ እቲ መምህር ንኣቶ ሃጸጸ ከምዚ ዝስዕብ ምክሪ ለገሰሉ፡-
    ኣቀዲመ ግን ሓደ ነገር ክላቦዎ ዝደሊ — እታ ዛንታ በቲ ሽዑ እያሱ ዝተጠቀመሉ ድምጺ ጌረ ስለ ዘቅርባ ገለ ሰባት ቂር ከይብለኩም፡
    ኣቶ ሃጸጸ ናይ ቃላት ትምህርቲ ወዲኡ፡ ኣብ መንበር ቅድሚ ኢስቴርሶ (ንሱ ዓንከል ዝብል ስም ሽዑ ዘጠመቖ) ኮፍ ምስ በለ፡ ናይ መጨረሻ ለበዋ ብመምህሩ ዝተዋሃቦ ፡- 1/. መፍትሕ ኣእቲካ ማኪና ምትሳእ (ብናቱ ቛንቛ ምጕሩምራም)። 2/. ጸጋማይ እግሩካ ብቀስታ ማርሻ ምእታው። 3/. ጸጋማይ እግሪለ ልቅቅ ከተብል፡ የማነይ እግሪለ ጽቅጥ ብለበልካ ቝጽሪ፡ ማኪና ክትከይድ እያ በሎ። ሃጸጸ እዚ ምስ ሰምዔ፡ ኣይ! እዚኣማ እንታይ እኒ’ታ! ካብ ዝብል ሓሳብ ተበጊሱ ይመስለኒ – በዚስ ግዲ የሎን። ኣይሰከፉ ፡ ጥራሕ ፡ ይመልከቱለይ’ማ በለ። ይኩን’ምበር፡ ተበገስ ምስኮነ ፡ እታ ማኪና ሕንቅ-ሕንቅ እንዳበለት ካብ ዘላቶ ምንቅስቃስ ኣበየት። መምህር እቲ ሽግር ንምፍላጥ ምስ ፈተነ ጌጋ ከምዝተፈጸመ ተመልከተ። በለ ከኣ ፤ ኣንታ! ኣይ ሓቃ እንድያ እዛ ማኪና ደኣ ሕንቅ-ሕንቅ ኢላ ዶው ክትብል ፤ ሃጸጸ ትቅብል ኣቢሉ ፡ ኤረ ኣነስ ጌጋ የብለይን ፣ ጸገማ ደኣ ይድለይለይ እምበር? ዋእ! ኣንታ! ክንዲ ጌጋካ ትእርምስ ተመሊስካ ማኪና ትሓሚ። እሞ እቲ ጌጋይስ ሕራይ እንታይ እዩ? ጌጋካዶ ? እቲ ማርሻ ኣብ ክንዲ ኣብ ቀንዳማይ – ኣብ ሳልሳይ ኢካ ኣእትካዮ እኔካ። ዋይ-ዋይ! ኣንታ ኣነስ ዘይረክቦ የብለይን። “ዝሓደረ ደኣ እንተ ንኤዋ እምበይ – ኣነስ ኣብ ሓደ እየ ኣእትየያ እኔኩ፡ ኢሉ ድረቅ ዝበለ መልሲ ሃበ ክብለ ተዋዘየ። እቲ ዘገርም፡ ሽዑ ነፍሰሄር እያሱ ከዘንትዋ እንከሎ ምስ እቲ ዝነበረ ኹነታት ልክዕ ብልክዕ ምግጥጣሙ እዩ።
    ቀጺለ ናብ’ቲ ዝበገሰኒ ጉዳይ ክኣቱ፡ ሓው ዳኒኤል ንሓፍትና ኢልሳ ጭሮም ኣብ ቃልዕ ሓቲትዋ፣ ናታን ዘይናታን ሂብዋ፣ ዘይምስላ ተጠቂሙ፣ ሕጊ ነጻ ፕረስ ጥሒሱ፣ ኣምኒኤል እያሱ ተጋጊካ፡ እዚ ኣውራጃውያን ወይለኩም! “ከም ቀደም ይመስለኩም፡ ውሕጅ ይወስደኩም” ኮታ…. ክንድይ ክብሎ። እዚ ሰብ ዝሓደረ ደኣ እንተ ሃልይዎ እምበር ክሳብ ክንዲ’ዚ ዘከይድ ኔሩ ክብሃል ዝከኣል ኣይመስለንን።
    መጀመርያ ክሳብ ሕጂ ሓፍትና ኤልሳ ጭሮም ኣብ ስርሓ ዘመዝገበቶ ዓወት ክከሓድ ዘይግብኦ ሓቒ እዩ። ክሳብ እቲ ሙሉእብርሃን ዝርከብ ከኣ ክትቅጽሎ ተስፋ ይገብር። ኮይኑ ግን እዚ ሒዛቶ ዘላ ስራሕ ኣዚዩ ዓቢይን ሰፊሕን ስለ ዝኮነ መሳርሕቲ ዝሓትት ይመስለኒ። ብፍላይ ከኣ ምስ ህዝቢ ዝተኣሳሰር ስራሕ ብባህርዩ ተነቃፊ እዩ። በዚ መሰረት፡ ዝኮነ ኣካል መሳርሕታ ይኹን ተዓዛቢ ኣብዚ ጉድለት ንርኢ ኣሎና ክብል ዝነበረ እዩ። ፈቲና ጸሊእና እቲ ሓቂ’ውን ንሱ እዩ። ስለዚ ሓው ዳኒኤል ንሓፍትና ኢልሳ ጭሮም ግልጽነት ይሃሉ። እቲ ስራሕ ይስፋሕ፡…….. ወዘተ ኢሉ ክሓትት መሰሉ እዃ እንተኮነ ዝተጠቀመሎም ቃላት ግን መረርቲ ኔሮም ንዝብል ነቀፈታ ኩልና ክንሰማማዓሉ እንክእል ሓሳብ’ዩ በሃላይ እየ። ብዝተረፈ ጓል መገዲ ሒዝካ ናብ ሕግታት ነጻ-ፕረስን፡ ጸለመ ኣማኒኤል እያሱን፡- ከም ቀደም ይመስለኩም ውሕጅ….. ዘላዕል ኔሩ ክብል ኣይደፍርን።
    ብዛዕባ ሕቶ እንተ ኮይኑ፡ ንኢልሳ ኣነ ባዕለይ ዝሓተትክዋ ሕቶ ኔሩ። ከምኣጋታሚ’ውን እቲ ሕቶ ከም ምስ’ቲ ሓው ዳኒኤል ዝሓተቶ ሕቶ ብከፊሉ ዘሳኒ ኔሩ። ጭብጡ – ኣብ ዝሓለፈ ውሑዳት ኣዋርሕ ሓፍትና ኤልሳ ዑደት ኣብ እተካይደሉ ዝነበረት ግዜ ካብቶም ብጸጋማ ኮፍ ኢሉ ዝነበረ ሓው፡ ሓደ ኣገዳሲ ዝኮነ ሓቤረታ ሃበ። ሕጽር ብዝበለ ንሱ ይብል፡- ልክዕ እዩ ንሕና ስለ ስደትኛታት ብዙሕ ተዛሪብና። ማለት ስለ ዝተገብረን ዝተረፈናንን። ኮይኑ ግን ንሕና ንእግረ መንገድና ዝረሳዕናዮ ነገር ኣሎ። ንሱ ከኣ ብሓቒ ኣቀልቦ ክንግበረሉ ዝግበኦ እዩ። ካብ መፋርቅ 1967 ጀሚሮም ዝተሰደደ ህዝብና ኣብ በረካታት ሱዳንን የመንን ካልኦት ጎረባብቲ ሃገራትን ተደርብዮ ኣብ ብቶንኮበት ዝተሰርሑ መዕቖቢ ዝነብር ህዝቢ ዝረሳዕናዮ ይመስለኒ። እዚ ህዝቢ’ዚ እኮ ህዝቢ ኤረትራ እዩ ። ኣብ ሱዳን እንተነበረ ዜግነቱ ዝቀየረ ከይመሰልኩም….. ወዘተ ዝብል ነበረ። እዚ ሓቤረታ ክወርድ እንከሎ ንልቢ ዘሎዎ ቀሊል ኣይነበረን። ተመሊስና ልብና ከምእንፍትሽ እውን ጌሩና እዩ። እምበኣርከስ ነዚ መሰረት ብምግባር ኣብ መጨረሻ ጊዜ ሕቶን ሪእቶን ምስ ኮነ ኣነ ከምዚ ክብል ሓተተኩ፡- መጀመርያ መን ከማኪ፡ ነዚ ሒዝክዮ ዘሎኪ ስራሕ ክሳብ መፈጸምታ ንከተብጽሕዮ ዕድመን ጥዕናንን እንዳተተምነኹ፡ ንስኪ ሓፍትና ኢልሳ ብከምይ ክትርብሒ ትክእሊ? እዚ ክብል እንከሎኹ፡ ንሓደ ጽቡቅ ንገር ክብዝሓልካ’ውን ስለ እትትምነዮ ኢለ’የ። ሳላ ሕማቕ እዋን ግዜ ሎሚ ኤረትራዊ ዘይነጠባ ክፍሊ ዓለም እንትሃልያ ኣንታርክቲካ ጥራሕ እያ። ብዝተረፈ ኣብ 6 ክፍለ-ዓለማት ተዘሪኡ ከም ዘሎ ንዓኪ ምሕባር ዘድሊ ኣይመስለንን። ክትራብሒ ክብል እንከሎኹ፡ ኢልሳታት ጥራሕ ዘይኮነስ ሙሳታት፡ ዔሳታት፡ ተስፋታት፡ ኣብርሃማት መሰልቲ፡ ምኻኑ እዩ። ምክንያቱ ንሽድሽተ ክፍለ ዓለማት ክትበጽሕዮ ትክእሊ ኣይመስለንን። ብውሑድ ከምቲ ንስኪ ኣብ ኤውርጳ ዘሎክዮ እንተዋሓደ ከምኡዶ ኣብተን ካልኦት ክፍለ-ዓለማት ኣይመድለየን ይመስለኪ? እዚ ክብል እንከሎኹ ግን ንስኪ ሓሚቅኪ ኣሎኪ ማለተይ ኣይኮነን፡-ክብል ምስ ሓተትኩ ብሸነካ ዝተዋሃበኒ መልሲ፡
    እዚ ዝሓተትካዮ ሕቶ ቅኑዕ እዩ። ይግረምካ ኣነ ንባዕለይ ስድራ ኣላትኒ። ካብ ናይ ስድራይ ግዜ ክንደይ እየ ዝጥቀም፡ ሕጂ ከኣ ከም እዞም ክትርእዮም ዝጸናሕካ መንእሰያት ኣብ ምዅስዃስ ኣሎና…….ወዘተ ዝብል ኔሩ። ኣነ ክኒኡ መልሲ ምመረጽኩ። ኮይኑ ግን ሓቲተ እንተወሓደ ተመሊሱለይ። እሞ ኣቱም ብዙሕ እትዛረቡ ዘሎኩም ኣሕዋት፡ ኣነ ከምኡ ኢለ ምሕታተይስ ኣውራጃዊ ስለዝኮንኩ ዝብል እምንቶ ኣሎኩም? ሓንቲ ነገር ክብድ ዝበለ ዝሓተተስ ካን ኣውራጃዊ ጥራሕ’ዩ ክከውን ዝኽእል? እስኪ ክሓተኩም ከም ኣጋጣሚ ኣቲ ጉዳይ ስደተኛታት ናይ ሱዳን ዘልዓለ ኣስላማይ እንተኔሩስ ኣስላማይ ስለዝኮነ እዩ ዝብል ግምት ኣሎኩም? ወረ ኣውራጃታት ድሕሪ ሎሚ ኣይክህልዋን እየን ዝብል ሞጎተ ካበይ ኢኩም ረኪብኩም? ኣውራጃታት ቅድሚ ሕጂ ኔረን፡ ሕጂውን ኣሎዋ፡ ንድሕሪ ሕጂ’ውን ክህልዋ እየን ኢለ እየ ኣነ ዝኣምን። ብምህላወን ከኣኣ ንማንም ሰብ ዝፈጥረሉ ክብደት የሎን። ብዝተረፈ ከምቲ ሓው ኣስጎዶም ዝበሎ ዝኮነ ሰብ ክሓትት መሰሉ እዩ። ዝሓደረ ሕማም ዘሎዎ ከኣ ሓኪም የናዲ ዝብል ምክሪ እዩ ዘሎኒ።

  • sMRET September 19, 2014

    The author of the article is a known anti amanuel and assenna (those those who are members of EYCS facebook group know about this guy. His message always are anti amanuel he even created and account under “Eritrea Media watch” to watch demo.archive.assenna.com. My question is to amanuel, didnt you know who the author is. How did you manage to fool Amanuel? By the way in facebook he always praise Elsa who ever comes after the author bark like mad dog:)

  • Eritreawit September 19, 2014

    WOW,
    A LOT OF ANDNET AROUND HERE, SMILING AND GIGGLING. VIVA ERITREA. WE WILL PREVAIL.

    demo.archive.assenna.com voice of the voiceless.

    MILKI YIFRES
    HIGI YINGES.

  • selamawit2 September 20, 2014

    Dear Amnuel Eyasu,

    everbody of us needs honest and contsructive advisers sometimes.
    I don’t know, what is going on in your foundation but you need to clear something soon – before assenna is damaged much more.
    Are you doing all the work alone or are there more people who affect the decisions of assenna???

    Who decides which articles get published or not – and what are the criteria?
    Who decides which comment are deleted or not – and what are the criteria?
    What are the rules for joining assenna (forums)?
    An the most important question after my opinion:
    What do you accept at demo.archive.assenna.com and where is the limitation?
    YOU as the hoster are the one who has the moral and factual right to assign the criteria!!!
    As beeing democratical doesn’t mean, to have no limitations – it also means to prevent democracy.

    But rules and criteria must be clear and valid for EVERYONE on of us.

    Anyway, keep it up! And if you detected some faults at, congratulations!
    Don’t give up – for detected faults give us the chance to improve…

    WE NEED YOU!

    • Genet-orginal September 23, 2014

      Dear Selemawit2

      Well said!
      I agree with your point 100%
      Genet-O

  • elos September 20, 2014

    dear Simon….

    i just want to be sure if assenna is blocking some comments on issues raised up here in this forum? some of my friends are red carded from assenna website after giving their comments in the issue of Elsa Churum. if it is true it will imply a lot of negative things in the future of our country

  • Truly Truly i say to you September 20, 2014

    I couldn´t understand why many people blaming Amanuel iyasu for host this kind of news. first of all he didn´t write self this article, but is another person. I believe the issue is national, so there is nothing wrong if we be informed about such kind of news through Assenna and then we debating about. Similarly i was not happy when you were blaming Meskerem and attacking Alem Goitom too, for whatever good and bad news for hosting in his website. But i do not mean Meskerem didn´t make mistake and should not to be criticized. In deed has few remarkable mistakes done for that part of the critic we practiced was ok. But i saw many of you when you attempting to expand hatter among Amanuel and Alem, and when offended for instance seeing PFDJ propaganda´s news. But Why? Don´t you know by this you were exposing only your wickedness? Because if not in Meskerem sees a news that you don´t like to hear , anyway people from other resources could also get it any information. What i mean is you have to learn and adopt democracy how it works. Don´t always adopt to hear what always like to hear only, sometimes you have to adoupt to hear other side critic and accusation even it hurts and when it even directs against you, your favourite party, organization or person as well would be directed. So when a person you hate, or a party, or a media hears criticize only to say hallelujah, but when you favourite one hears criticize to start blowing dust, which is stupidity, unfair and unacceptable.
    To come to the point, in my view in this debate two issue is very clear to me. The one is, human right violation investigation duty is not individual it is national, In deed it is national and supposed to be done national by capable many citizens including Elsa, we agree.
    The other accusation regarding money issue the writer talked about, I think in this point precisely the writer unknowingly exposed himself, as not for good motive and intention and fairly is criticizing the woman possible to say. Because the amount of money he blaming Elsa , comparing with costs of her remarkable humanitarian work to accomplish we assume that she could waste money, by no means should to come for such kind of doubt. Please just to reach the victimize people in need, how many times do you think she could fly and may for any invitation and seminar also you guess she travelled? Let say may 3, 4 times least. So the money this article writer blaming would it be enough even for plain ticket and hotel cost to cover without adding the possible another costs to anyone of us when traviling like that we facing, our relatives and freinds in need as that expecting help from us, thousends don´t you think they expect help from her? These and others costs if you add, do you think this article writer is healthy when doubt about money, despite other side he has a relevant argument?
    Anyway from right or wrong motive the issue in point one he raised because has relevance, it is better if Elsa urgently answers about, either in letter or in interview form, best in interview with brother Amanuel Iyasu rather than with Meskerem (Naz Yemane) or others media, because since the issue is raised in Assenna i mean. so that to avoid the caused unnecessary doubt about her in many people´s mind. It also best if she make the interview with Assenna because some people by their writing as if Elsa and Assenna have conflict propagating and to attack each other as that they blackmailing by saying because confusing us, we as people we need clarity. In this way we can´t lead the struggle and archive what we wants to see. If among comrades causes conflict see, we have to be solution makers , not conflict and hatter expanders among each struggle comrade or media or organization etc as some of you partly deliberately, but some unknowingly practising. How can someone except to see in free democratic Eritrea, without Amanuel Iyasu, Elsa, Dr. Alganesh or Meron Estifanos, be Alem Goitom or Awate media, Medreks of Dr. Andebirhan or Dr. Assefaw etc? The list has no end. What a stupidity though the common enemy is one!

  • Assenna September 20, 2014

    Assenna as a website tries to filter comments that create animosity among Eritreans, belittle the Eritrean people and history, comments that are not related to the subject raised. Some commentators continually try to use Assenna as a ground where they sow the seeds of hate against certain parts of our society be it in religious or regional matters. That is the reason some comments are not posted. Soon the posting guideline will be posted so that people make sure to adhere to them.

    • Genet-orginal September 22, 2014

      Thank you Assenna!
      Posting guideline. I support that.
      Some people are acting like big babies. They will start something and when they are challenged, they cry to no end. It is annoying. If we can’t handle the truth, other opinions and we are not able to learn from each other, why come to Assennna? I don’t think Assenna is for groupies or big babies. My opinion.
      Genet-O

POST A COMMENT