ኣቦ ወንበር ኮምሽን ንድፊ ቅዋም ኤርትራ ነበር ዶር በረኸት ሃብተስላሰ፣ ብሕግን ቅዋምን ተማሓዲርካ ንምንባር ኣብ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ዘሎ ባህግን ድሌትን ብመደረ ውልቀመላኺ ኢሳይያስ ክመውት ከምዘይክእል ገሊጹ።
ኣቦ ወንበር ኮምሽን ንድፊ ቅዋም ኤርትራ ነበር ዶር በረኸት ሃብተስላሰ፣ ውልቀመላኺ ኢሳይይስ ኣፈወርቂ፣ ንሃገራዊ ቅዋም ኤርትራ ኣመልኪቱ ሎሚ ቕነ ኣብ ቴለቭዥን ንዝደገሞ ብድዐ ብዝምልከት ምስ ድምጺ ኣሰና ኣብ ዝገበሮ ቃለመጠየቕ፣ ብሕግን ቅዋምን ተማሓዲርካ ንምንባር ኣብ
ኣቦ ወንበር ኮምሽን ንድፊ ቅዋም ኤርትራ ነበር ዶር በረኸት ሃብተስላሰ፣ ውልቀመላኺ ኢሳይይስ ኣፈወርቂ፣ ንሃገራዊ ቅዋም ኤርትራ ኣመልኪቱ ሎሚ ቕነ ኣብ ቴለቭዥን ንዝደገሞ ብድዐ ብዝምልከት ምስ ድምጺ ኣሰና ኣብ ዝገበሮ ቃለመጠየቕ፣ ብሕግን ቅዋምን ተማሓዲርካ ንምንባር ኣብ ልቢ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ዘሎ ዓሚቝ ባህግን ድሌትን ብመደረ ውልቀመላኺ ኢሳይያስ ክመውት ከምዘይክእል ገሊጹ።
ዶር በረኸት፣ ውልቀመላኺ ኢሳይያስ ነቲ ብናይ ሰለስተ ዓመት ጻዕርን ኣበርክቶን ኤርትራውያንን ህዝባዊ ተሳታፍነትን ዝተነድፈ ፣ ኣብ ምብጋሱን ምጽዳቑን ባዕሉ ኢሳይያስ ዝወዓለሉ ንድፊ ቅዋም ከይትግበር ዝተፈላለዩ ምኽንያታትን ውዲታትን እናፈጠረ ንሓያለ ዓመታት ዓጊቱዎ ድሕሪ ምጽናሕ፣ ሎሚ ሞይቱ ኢሉ ምሽክዕላሉ ዘሕዝን እኳ እንተኾነ፣ ልዕሊ ኹሉ ነቲ ስልጣን ናይ ምግባት ጥሙሑ ዝያዳ ከምዘቃልዐ ኣብሪሁ።
እዚ ከምዚ ዝኣመሰለ ኣብ ኤርትራ ክኸውን እዩ ኢልና ዘይተጸበናዮ ኣሉታዊ ፖለቲካዊ ተመክሮ፣ ዋላ ብደረጃ ናይቶም ኢሳይያስ ዘናሽዎም ዝነበረ መራሕቲ ኣፍሪቃ ‘ውን እንተኾነ መዳርግቲ ዘይብሉ ዘስደምም ቀይደ በተኽነት ምዃኑ ኣረዲኡ።
ኣብዚ እዋን’ዚ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ብጥልመትን ምትላልን ኢሳይያስ ነቒሑን ተማሂሩን ስለዘሎ፣ እዚ ሕጂ ኢሳይያስ ክነድፎ እየ ኢሉ ዝምድረሉ ዘሎ ቅዋም ሕጋውነት ኮነ ህዝባዊ ተቐባልነት ክህልዎ ከምዘይክእል ‘ውን ኣገንዚቡ።
ኣብ መወዳእታ ዶር በረኸት፣ ኣብ ውሽጥን ወጻእን ዝርከብ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ፣ በዚ ቅብጸትን ፍሽለትን ዘበገሶ መታለሊ ናይ ኢሳይያስ ፖለቲካ ከይተደናገረ፣ ምልካዊ ስርዓት ኣልዩ ብቕዋምን ልዕና ሕግን እትመሓደር ፍትሓዊት ኤርትራ ንምትካል፣ ብውሽጥን ወጻእን ተኣሳሲሩ ስሙር ግንባር ብምፍጣር ቃልሱ ብዝያዳ ከጓሃህር ተላብዩ።
ክቡራት ተኸታተልቲ ድምጺ ኣሰና ምሉእ ትሕዝቶ ናይቲ ዶር በረኸት ምስ ኣሰና ሎሚ ዘካየዶ ቃለመጠየቕ ኣብ ናይ ጽባሕ መደብ ራድዮ ኣሰና ክቐርበልኩም እዩ።
Mike January 4, 2015
I think to the most part the comments are good. You all have stayed within the discussion realm.
Few have expressed truly what is wrong and few others gave me a softer punch – I expected the worst however.
I only reflected what this man, Bereket, stated himself as to what was wrong with the 1997 draft. I am sure many of you would like to think the draft was great or that is all we got and let us work that first….etc – let me give you a news – not a all (or every) constitution is great. Not even close. Even the greatest Democratic countries in the world w/ constitution have poorly written or some bias in it. It is just my opinion. So let us not just simply harp why it is not instated – it too might have something twisted. I think few have read it but majority has not.
Some of you invoked Bereke is elderly, educated, served “several rulers”….etc I don’t want to get there. I respect you all regardless of your background, but the past should never hold us in chain-of-pride and the future should not wait for reasons of fear. Wisdom comes from everyone and all ages.
I think we should focus on removing the crumbling system in Eritrea (not dwell in the past as ormoay has stated above). Not to digress here but even the founding fathers of the great nation of USA waited until the are done with the king to come up with a working and living document. so my friends…I mean removing all and not just Issayas should be number one goal/mission. Then and only then that Eritrea will move towards Peaceful mountain top. Not what 1997 draft or drafting body has to say…they were given to do it right and that only history will give its judgment. As for now we are all implicated in this bias where we only seek what interested us individually.
Focus on removing the cancer in Eritrea….. Peace to Eritrea and the world.
p.s. I have never met nor do I know Bereket. And yes – he might probably be my grandfather…and I say grandfathers love us all rgaardless I hope but they also like to hear honest grandsons rather than wishy washy -no?
sidiabdu@gmail.com January 4, 2015
What we need I think is a collective mind transformation. The current level of our thinking is so numb beyond salvage. What else, It is mind boggling to think a large number of our population identify themselves with this regime. The regime that brought us war,havoc,exile,you name it. These should have being a prescription to the regime’s demise. The Eritrea’s population is in a constant grieving mode as more and more night news reports bring us a sad story of our compatriots fate be in Sudan or the Mediterranean.Boy it is sad. The man comes on TV and peaks like GOD. Some one has has to break the bad news to him ” we don’t want to see his face”. The more he hangs on to power,the more work will require to undo his disaster. His highness is unaccountable to any one. The good news is the regime is poised to self destruct itself from within just like the untreated cancer does to the human body. Though resection would have left the rest of the body intact in many instances.
ghebre woldemichael January 4, 2015
ንሕና ቅዋም ይተግበር ንብል ነርና ከም ደለይቲ ፍትሒ ኤግደፍ ኩነታት ስለዘይ ኣፍቀደ አምበር ክትግበር አዩ ዪብሉ ነይሮም ሕጂ ግን ንሳቶም ኣሕሲካና ኢሎም ስላማዊ ሰልፊ ኪገብሩ ኣለዎም ኪንሕግዞም
Nega January 4, 2015
as if kwam saves everything
sidiabdu@gmail.com January 4, 2015
Civil discussion is required to produce results. That is why we need a complete top down enema to clear the minds and to transform them to see the reality of the day
Tegisti January 4, 2015
Dr bereket etta quwam nay mejemerta be Milyon ahteimka . Ab diaspora zello hezeibi teteadelll. Please reprint in million copies and distribute to the whole eritreans in diaspora . May Will help you to contribute for printing
Yoditta gaul Yemane January 4, 2015
A constitution document is a political document before it becomes a codified legal document.
This will entail that the constitution process is inherently more of a political process than legal process.
I wish the good doctor could have been stood his ground advocating for a comprehensive political process..
for without that there will be no legitimacy and credibility from the eyes of the excluded (the minorities).
If every citizen couldn’t take it as his/her own document worth to defend it…. then what?
If every citizen either directly or indirectly be part of the process then every citizen will defend the
product of the process. Let’s all do the right things that unite the Eritrean people by responding to
their grievances and major concerns. Our good doctor once said, “I was not in the position of deciding
whom to invite or appoint. One response in such a situation would be to make a point of principle and
decline to serve as chair of the Commission”. It was not an ideal situation, but one which was, in the
circumstances, the only available option.
As all of us understand any constitution is by the people for the people of the nation. In the making of
any constitution all concerned parties should participate, but the constitution supervised by our good
doctor was tailored by Isaias for Isaias, and Isaias has all the right to read or shelf it. Our good
doctor prepared the constitution for Isaias and his mistake now is he wants to tell us that he prepared
it for the people of Eritrea. What a sham!
As far as the process was wrong, the result was a catastrophic one to our people. Frankly speaking, our
good doctor participated in the catastrophe the people of Eritrea lives or finds itself today. If our
good doctor had been stood high at the time and said no the dictator and declared that to the people of
Eritrea, the course would have been different. Believe me, you would have saved the people of Eritrea
from the present desperate and shameful situation.
Sol January 4, 2015
Yodita
very fair and straightforward.
How can people drat a constitution in an unconstitutional situation and under a totalitarian rule?
Simon G. January 4, 2015
I would say something is better than nothing, which what we had for the last ~2 decades. The 97 draft is a lot of things, which is better than something and definitely much better than nothing. Amendments are there to fix any loopholes or errors.
Dr. Bereket did or try to do his best and he should be respected for that. Actually, form all the Drs or PhD holders that I know, he earned my highest respect.
If you don’t like Dr. Bereket, try Dr. Gidewon.
Yoditta gaul Yemane January 4, 2015
Brother Simon G.
“If you don’t like Dr.Bereket, try Dr.Gidewon.
Respected brother, we are not in the competition of trying the Coca cola or Pepsi cola.
However, just to please you if I have to choose then I would choose only one “Dr” YG – Yosef G/hiwot.
There is your answer Mr Simon G. Since you really pushed me then it is always the undisputed champion of the ordinary and genuine people of Eritrea.
WediHagher January 4, 2015
“However, just to please you if I have to choose then I would choose only one “Dr” YG – Yosef G/hiwot.”
Yoditta gaul Yemane
You criticize Dr. Bereket for not being a perfectionist, and then you embrace an Ethiopianist who do not even believe in Eritrean identity.
For YG there are Habeshas but not Eritreans. And Habeshas according to him are Ethiopians. He has much in common with Gebru Asrat than with Eritreans. Some one who took it as his job to insult Ghedli, Tegadelti and Eritrean Muslisms.
Abraha Atsefaha January 4, 2015
Dear nationalist if you are asking of Dr. Gidewon Abay he is one of those new puppets of recently time ሓደ ካብቶም ሉኡኻት ናይ ኣቶ የማነ ገብረኣብ ኮይኑ ኣብዚ ቀርባ እዋን ኣንጻር ሐፋሽ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ኣብ ስደት ክምድርን ክፍላፈስ ዝጸንሔ ካብ ፖሊካ ሐሊፉ ናብ ሃይማኖት ኣንጻር ኣቅሺሽቲ ተዋህዶ ብዙሕ መዲሩ ነዚ ድማ ግዜ ንጽበየሉ ኣሎና፡ መኽንያቱ ኣንጻር ሃይማኖት ክኒሻ ወይ ካልኦት ኣይመደረን፡ ስለዚ ጉዳይ ቅዋም ንዑኡ ዝምልከት ኣይኮነን ኣብ 1997 ቅዋም ክጻሐፍ ከሎ ንሱ ኣብ ካልእ ዓለም ኢዩ ዝነብር ነይሩ ደቂ ሐፋሽ ዶብ ክሕልዉ ከሎዉ ደቁ ድማ ኣብ ዝበለጸ ቤት ትምህርቲ ይማሃሩ
ክምኡ ዶ/ር ንክኾኑሉ ይጽዕር ነይሩ ናይ መናባብሩኡ ጉዳይ ምስ ኣጽፈፈ፡ ኣብዚ ቀርባ እዋን ኣብ መድረኽ ድይቡ ዝምልከቶን ዘይምከቶም ኪኢለዮ ብምባል ዓጀውጆው ክብል ይረኤ ኣሎ፡፡ ስለዚ ሐደ ዘይኮንስ ቡዙሓት ለባማትን ምሁራት ሕጊ እንዳባ ዝፈልጡ ኣሎዉና……..?
tamrat tamrat January 4, 2015
Who and what have brought change in ethiopia and eritrea?
The etiopians have known the answer always. They knew the short commings of the king and removed the king in the most civlized manner. Check on you tube and take the time into concideration and the precaution taken in avoiding civil war and disintegration.
They accepted the revolution brought by the mass but did not like dergs policies. They mobilized the whole nation suffering exstra taking the unity as a priority.
They removed derg and move on forca better system.
They have stopped the pfdj malicious program not to affect negativly the change in ethiopia even tried to remove it but the support for the pfdj was enormouse.
Some eritreans tell us all these miracles is done by eritreans as a gift for ethiopians. But I say the facts in the past and now show us cristal clear.
Remember the number of ethiopians who sacrifice be it for uniting eritrea or independence of eritrea is 10 times more than eritreans.
The thooth less pfdj leads the country for 25 yars proves once more.
.Both eritreans and ethiopians know thr right way of serving our multi ethnic socities. So stopp downplaying the ethiopians efforts. Instead cooprate sit and discuss how to remove hgdef which took power by many combined surcumstances.
Eritreawit January 4, 2015
Tamrat Tamrat, are you out of your mind?
“Remember the number of ethiopians who sacrifice be it for uniting eritrea or independence of eritrea is 10 times more than eritreans.”
We witnessed when EPLF fighters handed TPLF the power in ADDIS ? stop your one sided dinal, Ethiopian leaders Weyane/whatever they are happy their cousins in Asmara pulling down Eritrea and its people to the ground,the Ethiopians think We go back to ‘Mother land’ if we suffer enough by the hand of the PFDJ. IT IS NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.
tamrat tamrat January 6, 2015
Study history. Ethiopians them selves gave you eritrea on silver plate and look what you are doing. Look back in 1991 and 1998 and you undrestand who is a giver and a taker. Ethiooinans inkluding eritreans suffered during derg time due to to monsters derg and shabia. Derg is removed thanks to ethiopians and eritreans while shabia continues making hell for both. Ethiopians challanging shabia doesnt mean free from suffering. Imagine we use all the human and money power on development. You dont understand this because it is beyond your brain wahed capacity.