Visit the new AsenaTv Website

https://asenatv.com

Where Soccer Has Been a One-Way Ticket Out

By JAMES MONTAGUE The New York Times: KIGALI, Rwanda — In the fading light and steady rain at Amahoro Stadium, the Eritrea national soccer team trained in silence Monday as it prepared for one of its

By JAMES MONTAGUE
The New York Times: KIGALI, Rwanda — In the fading light and steady rain at Amahoro Stadium, the Eritrea national soccer team trained in silence Monday as it prepared for one of its most important matches since securing independence from Ethiopia in 1993.

The team, known as the Red Sea Boys and ranked 190th by FIFA, will face Rwanda on Tuesday in the second leg of their 2014 World Cup preliminary qualifier. If Eritrea wins, it will advance to the second round, a group stage.

But the most important number after the match may not be how many goals Eritrea scores, but how many of its players are on the plane back home.

This is the first time Eritrea has played away from home in two years. The last time the national team left Eritrea, for a regional tournament in Kenya in 2009, the entire team disappeared after a match, later claiming asylum at Nairobi’s United Nations High Commission for Refugees before being resettled in Australia.

Eritrea is considered among the most repressive countries in the world. The players’ defections gained attention internationally after a diplomatic cable titled “Eritrea’s squabbling colonels, fleeing footballers, frightened librarians” and dated Dec. 15, 2009, was released by Wikileaks. In it, the United States ambassador Ronald K. McMullen wrote: “Human rights abuses are commonplace and most young Eritreans, along with the professional class, dream of fleeing the country, even to squalid refugee camps in Ethiopia or Sudan.”

A 2011 report on Eritrea by Human Rights Watch described how torture remained routine, how the continual state of conscription has destroyed the economy, and how up to 50,000 Eritreans live in Ethiopian refugee camps.

Athletes are among the few who can leave the country legally. But many do not return. In July, 13 players from Eritrea’s top club Red Sea fled in Tanzania. Four players from the same team defected while playing in Kenya in 2006.

“Yes, something must be mended and we are trying to find out the cause,” said Kahsay Embaye, the vice president of Eritrea’s soccer federation. “But sometimes it is also a conspiracy by some people who are abroad.”

In a section called “Soccer Team 1-Regime 0,” the diplomatic cable described reports of the players’ defections, and said that President Isaias Afewerki would “undoubtedly try to twist logic in some way to blame the United States” for the players’ leaving.

But the cable also described the small country’s passion for soccer. “Many dusty streets in Asmara are filled with urchins kicking an old sock stuffed with rags back and forth between goals made of piled stones,” the cable said. “Senior government and party officials are avid fans of the British Premier League and sometimes leave official functions early to catch key matches.”

Of the 12 players who defected, 11 went to Adelaide, Australia. Local soccer clubs arranged for four of them to share a house and arranged local jobs for them. Nevi Gebremeskel, a 21-year-old defender who just finished his season playing for White City Woodville, a team in the South Australian Premier League, said that the Eritrean soccer officials led him to flee, not the government.

“We need to play and we had a big problem with the federation,” he said in a telephone interview. “If anyone got the chance to go overseas, any team from any country, they didn’t allow them to go.”

Speaking of the day the players defected, Gebremeskel said they had a meeting after the team finished the tournament in Kenya.

“We were all having the same thoughts, so we had the big meeting,” he said. “Yes, I was scared. “We didn’t have anything when we left. All we had was our kit.”

Negash Teklit, the team’s coach, smiled awkwardly when the defections were mentioned. Teklit, a former star of the Ethiopian national team before Eritrea gained independence, has coached the team for 11 years and was in charge at that tournament in 2009.

“This problem is not Eritrean only,” he said. “This is a problem of African youths all over the world. They can immigrate from one country to another.”

He added: “We have many players still. This generation and especially this team is the best team.”

The team had to be rebuilt from scratch. A team of teenagers, picked from Eritrea’s under-17 and under-20 squads, train in the jerseys of their heroes from England, France and Italy.

Eritrea’s young team has managed to compete. The first leg against Rwanda, played at altitude in Asmara, ended in 1-1 draw.

Teklit said that the federation learned its lesson and that some players were allowed to play professionally in a handful of friendly countries to avoid any more embarrassing defections.

“We make the players go out and get professional exposure in Qatar, Sudan, Kuwait,” he said. He added: “We need the players to play at home first and not to hold them. But if they want to go, they can go.”

Tuesday’s game is the first litmus test of Eritrea’s new policy. Embaye, the federation vice president, remains confident that after the game with Rwanda, all of the 18 members of the squad will return home.

“That is 100 percent sure,” he said.

In Adelaide, Gebremeskel follows the national team. He said his fellow Eritrean players, two of whom play for Gold Coast United, one of Australia’s top professional teams, were still friends and had built a community around their shared experiences. He said he was convinced that more ambitious soccer players would follow the path he and his teammates forged.

“Life is very good here, very, very good,” Gebremeskel said. “Everyone is happy to live. If you need to work, you can work.

“Even tomorrow, after the game, the same thing is going to happen. Everyone has the right to a new life. I don’t think they’ll come back.”

 

aseye.asena@gmail.com

Review overview
46 COMMENTS
  • selam November 15, 2011

    eritrea lose 3-1 in kigali.
    please guys run away, and make ur mark on the downfall of the dictator!
    use the opportunity , for urselves and for the good cause of making the world know the absolute confussion and corruption the ER gov’t is going thru.

    • HGDF November 16, 2011

      If you are an Eritrean and if you know what you are saying, you wouldn’t say this. Do you think when some one goes out of the country is a loss to PFDJ ony? I don’t think so. First of all it is a loss for himselves and his family. Because it is less probable that he will go back even if things change the way you wish in Eritrea. If he returns his kids won’t return so it is a loss anyway for him and his family and Eritrea in general. So you are encouraging people to disappear from Eritrea for ever thinking that it would paralaze PFDJ. Very stupid and unwise idea. Or it may be the work of the enemies of Eritrea who want to see its you disappear for ever.

      • Rimabi2 November 16, 2011

        Hi Mr/Miss HGDF Thanks for you comment, but I would like to underline the word that you recon as for ever, what did you mean for even? Did you anticipated HGDf to survive for ever, that is wrong suggestion the presence of dictator is pain full for whole people of Eritrea. You need to ready HGDEF will disappear soon all will back to see our family and to build and practice democracy in our home. If you don’t regret for the word that you believe you will be penalize by the outcome soon. Eritrea will be free with the presence holly god who create us to live free. The people of Eritrea will pay back what he deserves as outcome of it.

        • Michael November 16, 2011

          Mr/Miss Rimabi2,

          Gaddafi is gone. Do you think Libyans who are in overseas will be back to Libya? Mubarek is gone. Do you think Egyptians who are in overseas will be back to Egypt? Mr/Miss Rimabi2 migration means lost. It is not a matter of governmnet. If you are out of Eritrea, did you know any one be it Italian, Greece, Poland, Leabanes, Egyptian . . . . who went back to his origin country? If you are honest, your answer is NO. Thus, we should not encourage our brothers and sisters to leave our home lands. After all, if a change has to come (be it in poletics, governance, economy) it is by the young people.

          BUT I ALSO ADVISE YOU THAT YOU BETTER THINK HOW TO GO BACK TO YOUR MOTHER’S WOMB THAN TO WAIT THE DISSAPPEARANCE OF PFDJ. Reason, because it is popular.

          • HGDF November 17, 2011

            MY comment above was to Rimabi2

        • HGDF November 17, 2011

          Come stupid guy! what I am saying is whether PFDJ is gone or not, once you are out it is difficult to return home. We have seen this fact in the past. Even if the parents return their kids remained there. What is the use of you when you return alone leaving your kids there. Don’t be blind and direct everything in blaming PFDJ. Eti Kalie nay mifirirah halewlewka entay kimiliselu.

    • Selam November 16, 2011

      Interesting to see other people abusing nick names you are not Selam please use your old nick name.

  • truly, Truly i say to you November 16, 2011

    Eritrea lose 3-1 in Kigali.
    There is no wonder about defeat. From the beginning the soccer team was allowed to travel to Rwanda not because there is a will to see the soccer win, but Pfdj were scared not to be asked by public if the soccer were not allowed to travel. Isayas and worshipers very well know the more the soccer qualifies, the more the players will get opportunity to flee. So that not happen,i am sure that there were coercion ( pressure) occurred by Isayas Afeworki, against the coach Negash Teklit, inorder Eritrean soccer not to lead them to victory, but to make it the defeat possible consciously. And also I can guess those players may also selected not because of talent, or have more were talented than others, but may be because they are too loyal to regime. As far as this regime is there, we Eritreans have no hope, neither in sport nor as nation even to exist as a whole. Saddened! It is realy saddened!

    • HGDF November 16, 2011

      You wouldn’t praise them if they win either. Would you? If they win and go back home with victory, you say they are loyal to the regime. If they lose, you say this is because they are not talented but choosen because of loyality to the regime. For you victory means only when they defect. Nothing else. You are not concerned about sport not even about Eritrea. Not at all! You are a loser and can’t wish anything good for Eritrea. You are so happy to talk about losses and failers, but would never say a word when Zeresenay, or the cycling team win a game. You are trying to play rubbish politics by telling people to abunden Eritrea. That would benefit no one but the enemies of Eritrea. It will not benefit you either, if you are an Eritrean. Believe it or not people who are leaving the country, including you, are lost forever. Even if you return, you kids won’t. So you guys should consider it a victory when they players go back home even if the lose the game.

    • Kozami November 16, 2011

      @truly

      Lie# 1 The soccer team was not meant to win, but PIA was scared the people would ask if they don’t travel.
      Lie# 2 PIA pressured Negash Teklit to ensure the players lose
      Lie# 3 The players were selected because they were more loyal to the regime
      Lie# 4 We Eritrean’s have no hope…in sport

      Proverbs 19: 2 “Desire without knowledge is not good, and whoever makes haste with his feet misses his way.

      Matthew 7: 21-23 “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ And then will I declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from me, you workers of lawlessness”

  • gasha November 16, 2011

    truley
    you wrote

    “As far as this regime is there, we Eritreans have no hope, neither in sport nor as nation even to exist as a whole. Saddened! It is realy saddened!”

    The eritrean cycle team won individualy and as ateam in eritrea. Truley nebsi hasot newri .
    You seem you love bible verses check this one.
    proverbs 19:5
    “A false witness will not go unpunished, and he who breathes out lies will not escape. “

    • Kozami November 16, 2011

      Gasha

      Truly is a demon, we unmasked him few days ago!

  • tegadalay November 16, 2011

    bad news for AMANUELE EYASU for assena what happen in TUNISIA is happening in ETHIOPIA meskerem .com jast put an article saying that atcher or memhir NAME YENE SEW GEBRE jast burn his body for anger over the ethiopian gov he is dead so this is the way the TUNISIA demonstration start so AMANUELE ESAYU what happen all this ajew jew in terviw your MASTER MELES as agood leader

    • Kozami November 16, 2011

      tegadalay

      It is shame that all the woyane stooges and woyane mass media is in news blackout in the untimely death of Ato Yenesew Gebre in the most abhorrent form due to violation of his human rights and that of 94% Ethiopians. They are busy to lecture us here about our beloved nation while their people are roasting in anguish.

      • Zekhtam Eritrawi November 16, 2011

        Qozami,

        You sure are throwing all your desperate chips where the coincidence is winning a jack pot if you will where you’re betting and investing no the unfortunate death of the young teacher that would potentially incite a mass revolution and ultimately bring about the demise of Weyane. But one thing we all sure bear in mind is that, if there is a huge discontent with in the population about the state of affairs in Ethiopia, whether a young man torches himself to death or not, the people will rise up in unison. However, what seems to be incredibly tragic and pathetic is, instead of trying to see the horrendous injustice, and gross human rights and an utter disregard to the agony and plight of the Eritrean people, Isaias and his thugs are hoping that the unspeakable agony of the Eritrean people will go away if the Weyanes disappear onto the thin air. An abusive husband is always troubled by his neighbour’s incessant plea with him to be nice and respectful to his wife where the husband wishes the death of his neighbour so that, he will continue abusing his wife. Whether Weyane is out of the way or not, Isaias will always be cruel and apathetic towards his own people. You’re too intelligent to miss the diagnosis and prognosis of Eritrea’s pathos.

        • Kozami November 16, 2011

          Zekhtam Eritrawi

          It is good to hear from you and hope all is fine. Now back politics, I think there is some validity to an aspect of what you say albeit overshadowed by an attempt to throw a left hook, the nature of politics, eh. As I interpret your message, no amount of change in Ethiopia would resolve the domestic problems of Eritrea. Tactics aside, I fail to see where we differ strategically. In the little that I know about the whole complex issue, I believe that Eritrea’s territorial integrity should be respected, democratic reforms should be carried out, the youth’s problems of long national service should be addressed. You are at liberty to characterize this from confusion to outright thuggery. Unfortunately, those are the issues of burning importance to people. Tactically, some believe they can effect the change by exacerbating the suffering of the people, other’s believe by working on the issue by starting withe existential threat to our sovereignty. I still think the latter is the rational segment.

  • Barentu November 16, 2011

    bshm tegadalay tshqT – teguwar,
    bpoletikawi guday etioPia Hamimka? wey gud! entay zemenu ina betsiHna::
    nezom b’amayt bHawi Hatsin gbtsawyan znedun ztkosun ertrawyan: ab foqodo bAti bereKa-sinay zmotun zzmetun: akalatom zmzHequn zelewu gedifkas bnay Hade etyiopiawi Hamimka?
    brgts yenie sew gebre tebaEn kurEn etyopiawi eyu: neti zre’ayo iftHawi zbelo bhiwetu kefililu: ab ertra wn kem’u z’ameselu bzuHat jeganun tebaAtn ab godagudi Era Ero bebHade ymotu alewu::
    bzaEba jeganu ertrwayan gn hgdefawyan zbelwo tsbuq yelen::
    kab hgdefsi yedHnena:

  • truly, Truly i say to you November 16, 2011

    Kozami, do you think the son of devil like you because call me, and to others fighters for justice, “Demon” that we will be surprised ? As about me I don´t consider as you dishonered me because I know let alone to the uncomplet not fully weak person like me, even To my Lord to who is fully complette holly God; Jesus Christ , the wicked persons like you as they called him “ You have demon, because you are a Samaritan) only because he had told them the truth.( John 8; 48) In now days according your interpretation you calling us demon, because not we are Eritreans but Woyane( Samaritan) . Anyway i understand what my Lord means when he confirmed us this “ No pupil is greater than his teacher; no slave is greater than his slave. If the head of the familly is called Beelzebul, the numbers of the family will be called even worse names! ( Matthew, 10; 24-25)

  • truly, Truly i say to you November 16, 2011

    correction,
    please read it the last sentence like this; “No people is greater than his teacher; No slave is greater than his master.”

    • Kozami November 16, 2011

      @truly

      Lie# 1 The soccer team was not meant to win, but PIA was scared the people would ask if they don’t travel.
      Lie# 2 PIA pressured Negash Teklit to ensure the players lose
      Lie# 3 The players were selected because they were more loyal to the regime
      Lie# 4 We Eritrean’s have no hope…in sport

      Proverbs 19: 2 “Desire without knowledge is not good, and whoever makes haste with his feet misses his way.

      Matthew 7: 21-23 “Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ And then will I declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from me, you workers of lawlessness”

  • truly, Truly i say to you November 16, 2011

    part 1
    Kozami, indeed “ Enthusiasm with out knowledge it is not only not good it wouldn´t help either you or your psychopath leader life to save too at last.” Actually your quote is rebounding to beat you. If you were real Eritrean,which obliged you when in unnecessary war within 2, weeks war when we lost more than 20,000 lives, many more disabled, milions displaced, lost territories still people forced to leave their home because of luck of leadership, You have to stand to say “enough!” like we doing! Lol! As about me ofcource I can assure most of my people not like you and your boss for well known own secret mission you confusing things, but because you able to disguise them, I know how they blindly deeply devoted to serve Isayas, but their devotion is not based on a true knowledge? ( Romans 10, 1-2)That is why I am weeping all the time, when I see my people doomed and perished every time and everywhere because of luck of knowledge.

  • truly, Truly i say to you November 16, 2011

    part 2
    As about many mighty works if anyone like you trusts and confident in external ceremonies, like to be feel Eritranism by contributing 2% taxes, (ofcourse you doing that not to help people, but to strengthen and to prolonging your evil boss power,)I have even more reason to feel that in right way, because I do also in my way to help my needy people and to save my nation. If you like I am also say like Apostle Paulos said it, I was circumcised when I was a week old, I am an Eritrean by birth not like you and president Deki Arba. And I was, still I am so zealous, if anything bad happened against my nation and people, (Phiippians 3; 4- 7)even when my national team loses matches not in normal sporting outcome, but because of many odd political reasons.

  • PFDJ(Popular Front for Dictatorship and Jail) November 17, 2011

    http://asmarino.com/news/1255-eritrea-pulls-out-of-regional-soccer-tourney
    of course these players will seek asylum if they go to play