Visit the new AsenaTv Website

Where has our humanity gone?…asks Shira Sebban

April 9, 2014 by Shira Sebban - J-Wire As an Australian Jew, I am ashamed by the treatment of asylum seekers in both Australia and Israel. I watch bewildered as the two countries I love descend further

April 9, 2014 by Shira Sebban – J-Wire

As an Australian Jew, I am ashamed by the treatment of asylum seekers in both Australia and Israel.

I watch bewildered as the two countries I love descend further in a harsh morass of immorality. Where has our humanity gone? Weren’t many of us, or our families, refugees once too?

On a trip to Israel in January, we found ourselves in the middle of a protest march in Tel Aviv, involving thousands of African asylum seekers. Sadly, as an Australian, their treatment is only too familiar to me, being reminiscent of what has been happening to asylum seekers who attempt to arrive by boat here – with one difference: Australia tends to lock up its boat people, who are not free to protest on the streets.

True, the Israeli government is now authorised to detain asylum seekers for up to a year without trial – it used to be three years until the Supreme Court intervened – in the remote Holot “Open” Detention Centrein the Negev. They can then be placed in indefinite detention until the State decides it’s safe to deport them.

Nevertheless, the Australian system is more severe still, with hapless boat people detained seemingly indefinitely in harsh conditions on the now infamous Manus Island or Nauru, with no hope of ever being settled here.

All officialdom seems to agree that such harsh treatment is necessary to deter further boat arrivals. Moreover, since December, boats have been turned or even towed back to Indonesia “when it is safe to do so”.  As a result, our government proudly proclaims that it is well on the way to achieving its popular promise to “stop the boats” all together, with the added advantage, it boasts, of having slashed the number of asylum seekers reaching Indonesia too.

Yet, as pointed out by Indonesian presidential advisor and former long-time foreign minister, Dr Hassan Wirajuda, “who can guarantee that next year they will not try again because the root causes, like conflicts, war, poverty, push people to migrate”?

Isn’t that why our families chose to leave their birthplace too? What about our grandparents or parents, who left Eastern Europe or North Africa, in quest of a better life elsewhere?

While Australia has now seemingly succeeded in blocking the arrival of boatloads of asylum seekers, the Netanyahu Government’s erection of the US$400 million fence on the Egyptian border in 2012 has practically ended the entry of African asylum seekers who, since 2006, had been making the often harrowing trek from war-torn, dictatorial, famine-ridden Eritrea and Sudan.

Everyone knows that Israel was founded by and for refugees and that Australia too has benefited tremendously from their contribution. True, by world standards, numbers of asylum seekers to both countries are now low: Israel is contending with about 55,000 African asylum seekers – less than one percent of Israel’s population – while in 2012-13, just over 24,000 asylum seekers arrived in Australia by boat.

Contrast this with the more than 45 million people worldwide – an 18-year high – forcibly displaced due to persecution, conflict, violence and human rights abuses, including more than 15 million internationally displaced refugees and close to a million asylum seekers.

Overwhelmed by the sheer enormity of it all, it can seem easier to bury our heads in the sand. But haven’t we been taught that to save a single life is as if we had saved the entire world?

The Australian government claims to be acting out of kindness: unseaworthy boats have to be stopped to prevent unscrupulous people smugglers from taking advantage of the desperate, luring them to their deaths. After all, the statistics are stark: more than 1000 people have perished at sea, while the lives of more than 6000 children have been put at risk.

Moreover, what about the 13,750 protection visas – down from 20,000 last year — on offer to those whose places under Australia’s humanitarian programs have been “usurped” by “self-selecting asylum seekers”, those so-called “queue jumpers”, who, or so the argument goes, are really “economic migrants” with enough money to buy a place via people smugglers?

The Australian government’s military “Operation Sovereign Borders” brands such “maritime arrivals” as “illegal”, just as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu accuses African asylum seekers of being “illegal infiltrators looking for work” – despite the fact that the 1951 UN Refugee Convention, to which Australia and Israel are both signatories, clearly recognises the right to seek asylum from persecution no matter how you arrive (article 31).

Denied legal status, neither country allows those asylum seekers still able to live in the community, albeit provisionally, basic civil rights, such as the official right to work. Issued with only temporary visas and denied any chance of family reunion, a poverty-stricken underclass is being created under our eyes.

And yet, until now around 90 percent of boat people have ended up being recognised as refugees in Australia. In its latest cruel move, the government has now decided that refugees who arrive by boat will no longer be eligible for a visa. Meanwhile, in Israel, only 0.2 percent of Eritrean and Sudanese asylum seekers have been granted refugee status, despite the fact that many more of their countrymen have been recognised as such elsewhere.

Being cruel to be kind? Or rather, out of sight, out of mind?

Of course we cannot expect every asylum seeker to end up in Israel, Australia, or another first world country. Moreover, one day, circumstances may even improve so they can return home. Meanwhile, however, there must be another option to indefinite prison or ultimate deportation for those requiring protection. Surely the ends never justify the means.

As Jews, we are constantly reminded not to mistreat strangers because we ourselves were strangers in the land of Egypt … and Poland … and Algeria … So why not work towards a humane resolution of this global crisis, which respects the inherent dignity of our fellow human beings and treats others as we would like to be treated ourselves?


Shira Sebban is a Sydney writer and editor with a background in journalism and publishing.

Review overview
  • regret April 10, 2014

    Shira Sebban

    You do care & when you are criticizing Israel & Australia, you are doing it for the sake of the Jews & Austrialians .because you understand injustice against Eritrean is injustice against a Jew ,Austrailan ,Palestinian,Chinese…etc, A good number of Eritreans,including those who oppose the Dictatorship backhome are selectively outraged & even after living for decades in first world ther only thing we have changed is our wordrobe.
    thankyou for being of the voiceless, as for us we will just selectively criticize.

  • Yemane April 10, 2014

    Therefore love the stranger, as you were once stragers in the land of Egypt.. Deuteronomy 10:19.

  • rezen April 12, 2014

    To Ms. Shira Sebban,


    Your article (with your photo) appeared in an Eritrean website
    I read it with particular interest. Why? Let me admit, first because of who you are – not Eritrean! But your opening sentence attracted me most:
    “As an Australian Jew I am ashamed by the treatment of asylum seekers in both Australia and Israel”
    After that, my reading was based on humanity. We humans seem to have an ugly side and our follies seem to have no end.But then, let me tell you about a wisdom, reflected by a proverb in Eritrean language Tigrinyia – a language derived from an ancient ‘church’ language called Geez [comparable to Latin]. Warning: It is my clumsy translation – just give me credit for my daring attempt!!!

    It goes like this: “God created the mountain; but also provides ladder to tackle it”
    There you are: human follies may seem to be insurmountable mountain but then there are those human ‘ladders’ with undying spirit to conquer it and become hope to humanity. And so, Dear Ms, Sebban, that is precisely why you and friends found yourselves “in the middle of a protest march in Tel Aviv, involving thousands of African asylum seekers” Bless you all.

    Post Script to Management,
    I hope you will find comments made on Ms. Shira Sebban article worthy of transmitting them to her.

  • Mihretu Berhe April 14, 2014

    After I read Ms Shira Sebban’s article I felt like there is a light at the end of the tunnel. We, Eritreans, will be the Jews of Africa one day. Because we have the same characteristics as Jews have: We love our country like Jews love to Israel; We are very few people comparing to other African countries like Israels comparing to Arab countries; We are hugely dispersed all over the world like Jews were prior to 1940s; We have the culture of paying tax to our country where ever we are like the Israels have been doing since the creation of land of Israel; We have been under constant sufferings as the Jews suffered extraordinary misery all over Europe. Once the dictator is gone I am sure we will be over the moon. Thanks Shira.

  • rezen April 14, 2014

    “Once the dictator is gone I am sure we will be over the moon.”

    While at it why not to Mars or Jupiter! After all, didn’t the Ghedli produced the mighty “Yikaalo” or something like that?
    Amen or is it Inshalah!?

  • Berhe Tensea April 16, 2014

    Excellent job Shira I wish I was in London…….

    • rezen April 17, 2014

      As I said above, I hope Management,will find a way to let Ms.Shira Sebban see the commentaries above. I am sure she will be delighted to know that Eritreans heed the comments of all international personalities. Just a suggestion.