Visit the new AsenaTv Website

Be aware of the circumstance of forcibly returned Eritreans, stay tuned to what happens to them in Israel.

Mr. Chairman: To be  aware of the circumstance of forcibly returned Eritreans, stay tuned to what happens to them in Israel. I was delighted to hear the foreign affairs subcommittee hearing: Eitrea: A neglected regional threat,

Mr. Chairman: To be  aware of the circumstance of forcibly returned Eritreans, stay tuned to what happens to them in Israel.

I was delighted to hear the foreign affairs subcommittee hearing: Eitrea: A neglected regional threat, hold on September 14, 2016. Not for its prospect to improve relationship with the US, but just for the record. At the hearing, the state representatives correctly presented the state of affairs of Eritrea, and the reason why 5000 Eritreans are leaving their country every month. Poor records of human rights, unlimited military service, extra-judicial execution, forced labor, rape and slavery were among the reasons mentioned. To quote the representative “Eritrea is hemorrhaging its youth”, and “Eritreans are voting with their feet”.

The relationship between the two countries is very bad to the extent that there is no American Embassy in Eritrea. And it is hard to believe any improvements in the near future. It is not up to the US, it is Issaias of Eritrea’s personal chose. Unfortunately, for Issais, portraying the US as a strategic enemy to Eritrea, and to use fear mongering among Eritreans, that nobody but only and only Issaias could stand to the Ethiopian aggression, supported by the US is much important and crucial for his survival in power than the conditional (unconditional) development aid from the US. This is simple math in the Eritrean politics!

But, as an Eritrean in Israel, what struck my attention at the hearing was the question asked by subcommittee Chairman Mr. Smith to the Assistance secretary ambassador Linda Thomas-Greenfield and her response. Mr.Smith asked: “When Eritreans men and the woman flees into Sudan or to Europe or wherever, if they are brought back, what is the penalty that they suffered as a result of the attempted flight for refugee status? ”

Ambassador Linda tried to answer it this way: “I don’t know exactly what the penalty is if someone returned. I suspect it is not a good thing for them and that they would be either arrested or forced to continue their national service”. And asked for help from her colleague, the office director of East African affairs, who was in Asmara, the capital of Eritrea two months ago. His response is not any different: “I am not aware of circumstance of those who were forcibly returned, that doesn’t come to my attention”.

Well, Mr. Director, to be  aware of the circumstance of forcibly returned Eritrean from their host countries, stay tuned to what happens to them in Israel. I am not surprised that the American’s don’t know what happens exactly to those who deported back to Eritrea. If the Americans don’t know what happens to the four dozen of American embassy employees suffering in prisons in Eritrea for years. If they don’t know what happens to Siham Abdu, an American citizen suffering in prison without due process, the daughter of the former Eritrean information minister, who defected and asked asylum in the west.

isarel_habtomNor do I am surprised that the Director of east African afairs is not a ware of circumstance of forcibly returned Eritrean. Except Israel, I am not a ware of any country that threatens unlimited detention or deportation to Eritrean asylum seekers. Egypt deports, but it is not a signature to the refugee convention. In the countries that Israel likenes itself, the west, let alone unlimited detention or deportation of Etireans, their acceptenace rate for refugee is more than 85%.

The policy in Israel is to encourage deportation under the so called “voluntary return” process, through prolonged detention, exclusion, and grants. Nobody knows exactly what happens to those Eritreans forcibly deported back to Eritrea from Israel, perhaps some of them are re-enslaved in the military, and others are imprisoned, but what happened to them in prison?. But, at least, we know that three Eritrean asylum seekers who left Israel for a third country as a result of the Israeli asylum policy have been executed by the Islamic State (ISIS) in Libya.

In fact, the hatered towards African asylum seekers in Israel is crystal clear, one that unites the Kenesset; from opposition leader Herzog, who thinks as long as Isaias like Assad didn’t use chemical weapons to kill Eritreans, Ertireans fleeing their country are not considered refugees, to Yair Lapid, to the Prime Minister, who loves to portray the presence African asylum seekers as a democratic, demographic and geographic threat to the state of Israel.

As a result, Israel instead of playing a positive role, it exacerbates the refugee crisis, by deporting Eritrens back to African countries, which contains the largest numbers of asylum seekers. Since those deported to Africa continues to the Europe, this endangers their life and exacerbates the refugee crisis in Europe. By doing so the state of Israel denies its very commitment to the refugee convention that it helps draft, gives it’s back to the current refugee crisis, and betrays its moral foundations.

Although, the recent decision by the court of appeals is welcoming, and an opportunity for the state to look into ways to contribute to the current refugee crisis constructively, by treating the asylum seekers residing in the country. It is yet to be seen. But for the time being, I advise the Americans to stay tuned to what happens to Eritreans in Israel to be a war of the circumstance of forcibly returned Eritreans.

Habtom Mehari

An activist for political change in Eritrea, is a PhD candidate at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Review overview
  • The Habesha September 21, 2016

    While first and foremost my heart goes to my fellow Eritrean kilil people I also understand the fear the Jewish state has of being outnumbered by non Jewish people ,The Jewish people have suffered more persecution by Christians begginibg in the 3rd century and about 900 + years ago by the Crusaders and recently by Nazi Christians …etc..It is really understood the Jewish nation to mistrust others but ,I hope they can find a system of non citzenship refuge to our people.

    My heart goes to fellow Eritrean kilil youth

    • Muhammad September 22, 2016

      እዚኣ ደኣ’ሞ ካብታ ዓሊ ዓብዱ ኣቦይ ዝኣሰርዎስ በዲሉ ኢዩ ይኸውን ዝበላ ብምንታይ ትፍለ? ዶስ ንስኻ, the so called ተቃዋማይ ስለ ኮንካ ኢኻ? ዓንጾ ዓንጾ ንማዕጾ ኢዩ እቲ ነገር፥ ደሓር ከኣ ግዳያት ናይ ተመሳሳሊ ግፍዒ ዝያዳ ክደናገጹ ምተገበአ ይመስለኒ: እቲ ቀንዲ ምኽንያት ከምኡ መግበሪኦም ከማኻ ዝኣመሰሉ ንከመኽንዩሎም ከይተሓተቱ ንኸዐርይሎም ዝተሰለፉ ባንዳ ከም ዘለው ኣንዳዕዲዖም ስለ ዝፈልጡ ኢዩ፤

  • k.tewolde September 22, 2016

    For the Eritrean youth,how about exploring this option,organize,draft a plan,pick up your pants above your waist,tighten your belt and go take back what is righteously yours,instead of looking for something like a flat and few monthly handout in the west ,you can have the gold, potash,iron ,zinc,potential vast natural gas reserves and hundreds of miles of seashore line to feed your nation and export to others………………….If you are not going to do it ,nobody is going to do it for you.Go tell your peers that you left behind and show the stone breakers that they are getting ripped off by the few old goons who are hiding behind multicolored curtain and sucking the life out of you.You will be surprised how easier that task is than the current flight option that’s costing the nation tens of thousands of you.Give it a shot and see HGDEF haul ass out of town in no time,and redeem those who fell to give you the MANNA of your homeland..

  • EriConcern September 22, 2016

    I can’t believe a PHD candidate could write this kind of rubbish (not only the language). And why do you have to lie? “………o the extent that there is no American Embassy in Eritrea…”. What an idiot. There is an Embassy. If you mean an ‘Ambassador’, admit it and immediately apologize to your audience. Just tell the truth by contacting those who are returning to Eritrea. They are provided with a multiple exit ‘Visa’ (7 years) and nothing has befallen to them so far. Read Edward Said’s ‘Representation of the Intellectual’. Just represent the truth and don’t mislead people.

    • Gaym September 22, 2016


      The author is not lying, I can understand that you don’t understand what Embassy. is in one country. Please refer a dictionary you don’t understand the meaning of Embassy. Embassy is the official residence or office of an ambassador. And as you have rightly mentioned there is no American Ambassador in Eritrea, therefore there is no American Embassy in Eritrea. The building near the Sematat School alone couldn’t not be an American Embassy, it is just a building,

      • Almaz September 22, 2016

        A resident in Embassy setting is called a chancery (official residence for charge d’affaires or Ambassador.). An Embassy is embassy do not split hairs


        • Almaz September 22, 2016

          A resident in Embassy setting is called a chancery (official residence for charge d’affaires or Ambassador.). An Embassy is embassy do not split hairs


  • Asmerom September 22, 2016

    The experts of embassies, ambassadors and charge d’affairs, why don’t you tell us or enlighten us
    with your expertise what the state of Eritrea has in the United States of America?
    Could it be a shifta bandit from higdef mafia organisation that is representing Eritrea in USA currently?

    • Alamz September 22, 2016

      Okay gladly– The government of Eritrea got an embassy in Washington D.C, and is currently represented by a charge.. By the way, either WE like it or not the CURRENT legitimate government of Eritrea is represented by a party PFDJ. So, accept and live with it. You can not bring change by demonizing (wicked and threatening.) your country man/women and the whole Eritrea from thousands of miles away.