Visit the new AsenaTv Website

https://asenatv.com

Dancing to the Eritrean tune

MOHAMMED SELMAN: VOICES OF AFRICA Hostile neighbours Ethiopia and Eritrea passed the bloodiest decade of war in 2000, with a tragedy that consumed about 80 000 lives. Yet, a decade later, the two countries are falling

MOHAMMED SELMAN: VOICES OF AFRICA

Hostile neighbours Ethiopia and Eritrea passed the bloodiest decade of war in 2000, with a tragedy that consumed about 80 000 lives. Yet, a decade later, the two countries are falling in love in the northern Ethiopian regional capital, Mekelle.

For centuries the history of northern Ethiopia has been filled with gruesome war stories and the city of Mekelle bears special witness. Nearly every family has contributed human alms to horrific wars. Almost every household features photographs of beloved sons hanging on ramshackle walls.

In the nearby jungle Meles Zenawi, now the prime minister of Ethiopia, and Isaias Afewerki, now the president of Eritrea, shared the armed struggle against the Derg’s military junta. And after 30 years of joint struggle and bloodshed, Afewerki’s country achieved long-sought independence in May 1993.

Then, divided over the fate of the Kashmire-like border town, Badime, the best of buddies in the jungle became the worst of enemies in the palace. And for about 20 years, from their respective thrones, Zenawi and Afewerki led their respective countries in a resistance against each other.

Still at loggerheads, both now use monopolised media to ridicule each other and both give rebels free airtime to disseminate propaganda against each other’s governments. They even ban each other’s music. Unwritten law has Eritrea restricting Ethiopian music, especially in the port region of Mitsiwa’e.

This story, however, takes a different shape on the road to Mekelle.

Consider Selam-Bus, one of the few bus services in Addis Ababa with a daily departure to Mekelle. Unlike other transport services elsewhere in the country, Selam-Bus offers luxuries such as safety belts, a portable refrigerator, air conditioning and — most importantly — two television sets.

Twisted language
Aboard, Eritrean culture dominates TV programmes, with its music and movies featuring Eritrea’s official language of Tigrigna. Most passengers from Ethiopia’s Tigre ethnic group, of course, speak a twisted version of the same language. Many of Ethiopia’s incumbent bigwigs are also from this ethnic group, including premier Zenawi himself.

Yet, in spite of all the Ethiopians on the bus, the two-day trip seems to be sponsored by Eritrea.

Even Mekelle dances only to the Eritrean tune. Traditional restaurants blare Eritrean music, notice boards and cinema houses announce the schedule for Eritrean movies and glossy posters of Eritrean music stars decorate coffee houses.

This situation astounds Tsegaye G/Tensay (39), an Ethiopian who was born in the Eritrean capital of Asmara, where he lived half of his life.

“Music is my passion and my profession,” says the composer. After the intense war between the border nations, however, he was not able to enjoy Ethiopian songs in Eritrea.

But when Tensay returned to the Ethiopian town of Mekelle, through the assistance of the Red Cross, he found an Ethiopian city engulfed in Eritrean music. Mekelle, in fact, has three government-controlled FM stations that all enjoy playing Eritrean music, which is obviously not in the government’s interest. The fact is, listeners prefer the music of their “enemies” to their own.

“Even at their weddings the grooms urged me to play Eritrean,” says Amanuel, a popular disk jockey who works in one of the prominent nightclubs, Abyssinia. Almost 90% of the songs he plays are Eritrean though, he says “nowadays I try to mix some songs of our own along with Eritrean”.

His own small DVD kiosk rents everything from Bollywood to Hollywood, but local residents prefer Eritrean films. So adverts posted throughout the city shout “New Eritrean movies: coming soon!”

Every Saturday and Sunday youths flood the city’s recreation centres and TV houses — a cinema hall where people hunker down and watch international soccer and popular local TV shows on a big screen — which are addicted to Eritrean dramas.

Only the English Premier League draws bigger crowds. And these sites can tap into the Eritrean channel from Arab satellites and present it to large audiences in Mekelle, with no competition from Ethiopian TV.

Of course, the wide acceptance of Eritrean music and other art has to do with proximity. At some point in history, the two peoples were one. Mekelle and Asmara share language, culture and social fabric.

The war — politically but not culturally motivated and lacking social backing — split two brotherly nations only on demarcation. But there seems to be no demarcation in their hearts.

Mohammed Selman, a lecturer in journalism, is a freelance writer. He lives in Ethiopia. In 2009 he won the Excellence in Journalism award from the Foreign Correspondents Association in Addis Ababa
Source: Mail& Guardian Online

aseye.asena@gmail.com

Review overview
29 COMMENTS
  • Temesgen Medhanie October 13, 2011

    An ahh and a hmmmm moment to say the least. As much as the story narrates a heartwarming new realities, I would have personally liked to see the story reciprocated in Asmara as well. But of course, it sure is a pipe dream where bigotry is still the talk of the town where our brethren (down south) in culture and through the veins of history are taken for the children of the lesser gods. I can’t wait to see the reaction of the students of Sofia and Gidewon to the otherwise cuddling story. I bet the first line to appear would be, “Ezom z’bel’U’lu tsa’Hli z’sebru entay eilnayom”.

  • abdi October 13, 2011

    Ezom zekholesetom ed znekhsu,lementi AGAME degelom hizom ms korakurom ^^^ ytf’eu.
    To hell with their twisted agamegna.

    • Temesgen Medhanie October 13, 2011

      abdi,

      Hate is such a powerful force, it often has a life of its own where it overwhelms or takes over one’s psych. Do not hate for it could eat you alive. Show compassion, love, sympathy and empathy. Richard Nixon in his trying moment once said, “Always remember: others may hate you. But those who hate you don’t win unless you hate them. And then you destroy yourself.”

      • abdi October 13, 2011

        What ever you say,i still hate them and their korakur and the cheap ppl who supporting them for living,regard Nixon its his own opinion not a bible or Quran.

        • King maker October 14, 2011

          Eritreans also enjoy Tigrian music. I was enjoying the music of Abrham Ghebremedhin, Aziz, and Mahlet when I was back home. It is true playing Ethiopian music was taboo and could put you in trouble during the war, but it was never banned officially and it is was normal tp play it after the war. It is normal to hear Amharic music in a taxi in Asmara nowadays. If Tigrians start producing quality music, I am sure they can also penetrate the Eritrean audience more widely. Politics has nothing to do with it.

          • ahmed Saleh October 14, 2011

            It dosn’t amaze me to read the article in Ethiopia.WE have Ethiopian friends all these years in USA, we get comfortable to be around each other rather strangers. We always enjoy their music the same they do to ours, no big deal. We always had been victims of politics.Ethiopians especially Tigrayans lost thousands of their youth fighting beside our brothers for the
            same cause. Both of us paid the life our youth dearly. Now you try to tell me what happen is these innocent people fault.
            It is fair and righteous priciple I beleieve to condemn who uses politics of ethnicity, religion or region as a weapon to
            divide people. To be honest even our worst enemy the DERG REGIME didn’t use such tactics. Remember if you want to
            undestand people’s capacity from good relations with their neighbors, look first how they value and treat their own.
            Most of the times we seek the values of life over death, peace over war and freedom over authoritarism. Those chauvinists
            who preach all negative and hatred message to please their master, your time of judgment is coming closer.AS they say
            BETRI HAK’S T’KETN EMBER AYTISEBERN. Get lost you losers, haters low lifes, you make me sick.

          • abdi October 14, 2011

            you need identity check then!

        • Ertrawi October 14, 2011

          Abdi:
          You are in a rong place , this website is for genuen eritreans Like Temesge and alikes or others like Temesgen.

          Please stay away from this website. Mind you, a person do not have self confidence especially with regarding of Eritrean born but their orgin is from Tigray or Ethiopia, most of them sound exactly like you are.
          by showing your idiotic maner it won’t help you more Eritrena than ordinary Eritrean rather your stiupid maner help us to see that you are suffering by inferierity.
          please out u are not deserve to be here.

          • Temesgen Medhanie October 14, 2011

            Eritrawi,

            Part I.

            As they say, bad habits die hard. It could as well be like chasing a wind when one tries to see a change of heart when a heart is imbued with hatred, vengeance, and bitterness. The hatred towards Ethiopians particularly Tigreans still permeates our collective psych where it is hindering us from taking control of our otherwise kind self. To atone ourselves from this dreadful mind set, we need to see events in historical contexts where the Tigrean people through the annals of history have always been the underdogs, marginalized and of course looked down not only by us but by the very people who were supposed to be their custodians as well. I don’t pretend to be a historian, but as much as we are all students of history, we can educate ourselves so that, we won’t be hostages of hatred and instruments of propaganda machinery where the latter is used by a regime not only to divide an otherwise one people but to extend its power base as well.

          • abdi October 14, 2011

            You are right genuines like”temesgen”lol just wondering what r u doing here?good u admitted that u are not genuine,
            I know who I am and don’t need ur testimony or temesgens for that,may be u are right i deserve a better none “mahber andnet” website,
            but tel me who da h you are to tell to leave the site?
            Listen ya Agame i promise to leave the site if you stopped mentioning Eritrea or anything about Eritrea,deal?
            Otherwise u will see me again and again till ur mahber Andnet under the so called eritrean intellectuals disappeares.and u will never see what ur leader dogtor bereket wished as long as the genuine eritreans are alive.ya husur agame agent.

  • truly, Truly i say to you October 14, 2011

    To say least the text is talking about the similarity of the cultural tradition and the language similarities of the people of Tigray and the high landers of Eritrea? So what? What is new and needed to tell about? What makes wonder the author, if he listen for instance in Austria, music with German language,or in almost whole South American nations except Brazil, if he hears with Spanish language music?Why i go far, who will wonder if in East part of Ethiopia Ogaden region, in the city, if the people listen the Somali music, is their language and culture is not similar? or because of that Ogaden should belong to Somalia? I can also mention the Eritreans in west region that they like to listen more Sudanese music,because have same tradition and language. So what? What is needed to tail about? Finally after i hear at Meskerem net what the socalled intelectual Bereket Habteslasse for what politic he stands for i realize why the Eritrean oppositions getting weaker and weaker up to now, and why the PFDJ regime getting stronger and trustworthier by real Eritreans despite we all know Isayas isworking for distruction of our nation too . When i say these not because I don´t like good relation with our blood relatives with the South, but only because it is un timely and the way it is needed to bring together both nations is not based through love and mutual understanding but because it is needed through hatter, swart,despising, economical and political sabotage going only.

    • ahmed Saleh October 14, 2011

      Truly
      Let me call you Hakegna in tigigna. I read your articles always, I admire you for your positive and respectfull
      ideas. My point is we have people in highlands with same language and tradition marrying each other in their life,
      same those people bordering the SUDAN. But these stupid politicians on government position to cover their
      ass they blame people to create chaos to hate and kill each other. Don’t forget Ruanda! We GEBAR can not solve it.
      We need leaders who don’t encourage the blame, but step in and try to solve the problem to prevent its damage.

  • Semhar October 14, 2011

    Let freedom ring in Eritrea!
    Let freedom ring in Ethiopia!
    Let freedom ring in Sudan!
    Let fredom ring in Somalia!
    Let freedom ring in Kenya!
    Let freedom all over the world.

    All we need is to have a CONSTITUTION and abide by it.

  • Semhar October 14, 2011

    To all Eritreans all over the world!

    You live in a land of the free run smoothly by constitution.
    Why are you supporting the tyrant dictator to rule ERITREA with out constitutions?

    Let freedom ring in Eritrea!
    Let freedom ring in Ethiopia!
    Let freedom ring in Sudan!
    Let freedom ring in Somalia!
    Let freedom ring in Kenya!
    Let freedom all over the world.

    All we need is to have a CONSTITUTION and abide by it.

    • abdi October 15, 2011

      thanks for enlightening us,
      shm agame areyti beles Wey andnetawyan sheytti hagerom enquaE aykonen ember kale si dlayki belni.

  • Soira October 14, 2011

    There is no such Erirean name called Abdi

  • Barentu October 14, 2011

    This proves right what the good Dr. Bereket recently said that we have more in common with our brothers and sisters in Ethiopia. He added that given this deep historical, cultural and geographical relations, we may one day see this people come together rather than waste time and resources fighting each other. This can be any sort of integration, call it con-federal, federal … or whatever.
    Issias Afewerki had himself told an Ethiopian opposition web site three years ago: “… the future unity and integration of Eritrea and Ethiopia is inevitable … any thing is possible, I can only say the sky is the limit.”
    Isaias’ parents are originally from Tembien Tigray, so is Yemane monkey, Hagos Kisha, Yemane Charlie … all from Tigraian ancestry.

    • ahmed Saleh October 14, 2011

      Barentu
      I think you missed the point of our discussion. All we are saying is historically
      the people in Eritrea,Ethiopia and Sudan have common interest .But I don’t
      care what Dr Bereket, Isaias and others said, no one have an authority to
      discuss about the sovereignty of Eritrea. We lost close to 100,000 people
      to get back our freedom. So you and others like you BACK-OFF!

      • abdi October 15, 2011

        Ahmed bro,
        may be barentu is braver and made it clearer than temesgen but at the end they both heading towards unification as their doctor’s wishes.

  • Temesgen Medhanie October 14, 2011

    Eritrawi,

    Part II.

    To highlight but a few, as much as the province is located at the gates to the main land, it has always been a victim of invasion when foreign powers (read Europeans) set foot in a frenzy of colony where the Tigrean people felt the burnt and carry the burden till they were reduced into people with no dignity and pride to show off. Moreover, right before the end of world war II, when they rose up against the Emperor, the Emperor not only crushed the rebellion but was determined to punish them where they were left with no option but to trek to Eritrea where the latter was flourishing economically and striding on par with the other developing countries a swell. It was then only then, we came to know them, as servants, labourers, gardeners, sheQet’ti belles as well. The genesis of the pervasive derogatory remark “Agame” got misplaced from a name of a region into a label where one is considered a backward and at times a ‘back stabber”.

  • Temesgen Medhanie October 14, 2011

    Eritrawi,

    Part III.

    Fast forward, when the Tigrean people took matters onto their own hands in tandem with the Eritrean liberation fronts, a new dawn defined an era where the hopes and aspirations were to see Eritrea and Ethiopia rise to the occasion and transcend a generation which had been enmeshed in bigotry. But as events unfolded ten years after the facts, we got back to where we left off and found comforts as we entertained hatred and bitterness as a political expediency in a bid to justify our distorted political modus operandi. And yet, as much as our erstwhile enemies and latter day nemesis travel an extra mile to find commonality in music and films, we regrettably are stuck in our old hateful and spiteful self.

    • ahmed Saleh October 14, 2011

      Temesghen
      You said it as it is. Keep educating with your constructive ideas. YEKENYELNA IZI HAWEY

      • Temesgen Medhanie October 14, 2011

        Ahmed hawey,

        I always read and take your otherwise comments-of-a-substance to heart. Again, thanks for those kind words.

        • abdi October 15, 2011

          where you stand is getting clearer than ever, come out, and tell us what the intellectuals (unionists) meeting with meles was about? what ever you say ya agame you won’t reach what u want,you don’t know nor ur unionist what we paid to be where we are today and we are ready to pay more to erase you.and this IS a promise.

  • Belew October 14, 2011

    Not only do Tigrayans listen to Eritrean music, but every Ethiopian. Go to Addis Ababa and see for yourselves, everyone listens to Eritrean music, particularly that of Helen Meles, Abraham Afewerki, Qorcach, and other singers. Even in South Sudan, where Helen Meles is viewed as some goddess, they listen to Eritrean music and prefer it over their own. We are even witnessing that same trend in Khartoum and Kampala, where Eritrean music and entertainment is being requested by civilians at radio stations and TV channels. Just go to Ashrooq and Sudan TV, and watch Elsa Kidane, Mohammed Osman and Yemane Barya music being played.

    Eritrean music is a lot like Jamaican music in terms of small size but major impact. Jamaican music is loved by many throughout the world and is often copied. Eritrean music is loved by many neighboring nations and is even entering the American market for the consumption of white Americans (I kid you not, go to Seattle, San Jose, and other locations and see rock bands using Eritrean beats and hooks to make their music). It is to be recalled, Abraham Afwerki is the only African singer to sing in his native language and to be signed by a major western music label (Virgin Records). This was and still is unprecedented and it goes to show the strength of Eritrean music.

POST A COMMENT